• Follow us


Netflix v Spielberg and the Battle for the Future of Film | Digital Trends

netflix versus spielberg oscars battle future of film getty2Steven Spielberg Michael Tran/Getty

“Spielberg is such a douche.”

This was the Slack message I received from a millennial colleague after reading the recent news that the legendary director plans to get Netflix films — at least in their current release format — barred from Oscars contention at a meeting with his fellow Hollywood elite next month. It’s a succinct take on the situation, to be sure, but for slightly older film fanatics like myself, the beef between Spielberg and Netflix — one an iconic figure of the aging Hollywood guard, the other a shining beacon of the new cinematic frontier — is a bit more nuanced.

This is a battle for the very future of cinema as we know it.

For me, the current row between such powerful and disparate sides of the cinematic paradigm feels almost like being a teenager as your parents increasingly argue in the kitchen, ushering forth fears of the “D” word. “Don’t fight you guys!” cries the eternal juvenile id from deep within.

Quite frankly, I’m torn between these two sides not only because I love them both, but because both have some valid points to make. And make no mistake, while the two parties are ostensibly warring over somewhat frivolous awards ceremonies, this is emblematic of a larger philosophical battle for the very future of cinema as we know it and what can and can’t be called a film. As such, it’s worth taking a closer look at both sides of the argument.

Spielberg has a point

First, let’s talk about what Spielberg is trying to do, and why. While Spielberg has yet to comment on his plans publicly as I write this article, as Variety points out, there is little doubt as to his thoughts about the validity of Netflix films in their current state.

netflix versus spielberg oscars battle future of film gettySteven Spielberg Kevin Winter/Getty

“Once you commit to a television format, you’re a TV movie,” Spielberg told ITV in March 2018. “You certainly, if it’s a good show, deserve an Emmy, but not an Oscar. I don’t believe films that are just given token qualifications in a couple of theaters for less than a week should qualify for the Academy Award nomination.”

More specifically, it’s been reported that Spielberg wants to push for rules that would require Netflix to put any movies eligible for awards in theaters for an undetermined window (likely four weeks or more) before they’re available on your TV screen or mobile device.

It’s easy to write off his request (demand?) as that of a petulant, out-of-touch oligarch of Hollywood past; “old director yells at cloud” and all that. But whether he’s right in his stance or not, there is method — film-adoring method — to his madness. His words are strong ones (not to mention ones that seem to be fighting a losing battle), but he’s fighting for something that movie dorks like myself still very much believe in: The very survival of the theatrical experience.

People just don’t go to the movies as much as they used to.

“But movie theater chains make billions,” you say. “They’re not going anywhere.” And, as it stands, you would be right in your argument. In fact, 2018 was a banner year for North American movie ticket sales, with more than $11.8 billion raked in, a 6.8 percent increase over the previous year. Those big bucks come as movie ticket prices have increasingly risen as theater chains upgrade theaters to combat the home theater experience, but even actual ticket sales reportedly increased in 2018 by 4.8 percent over the previous year.

If the years preceding it tell us anything, however, this figure seems more of an anomaly than a trend. While 2018 was a mega year at the movies, it followed a three-year slump that saw 2017 register as the worst year for ticket sales since 1992, according to Bloomberg. For anyone who has been paying attention to the streaming landscape, this latter trend seems to be the one writing the story going forward. Unsurprisingly, with all the options out there from Netflix and company, people just don’t go to the movies as much as they used to, leaving the very theater industry itself in a state of flux, if not all-out doubt.

While Spielberg has made a few questionable decisions in his later years (Crystal Skulls, etc.), the man is a legend for a reason. He literally invented the blockbuster with Jaws, for god’s sake, and he’s helped push film technology forward for the better part of five decades.

Dolby Cinema how to use netflix secret codes tv example

That hasn’t just helped theater chain conglomerates like AMC and Regal rake in the bucks, it has created astounding new experiences like Dolby Cinema and IMAX with Laser which, in turn, trickle down to the home theater industry. Your Dolby Atmos soundbar, that vivid 4K HDR screen, and the very quality of streaming and Blu-ray films can thank the theater industry for a large part of the innovations that make us all happier at home.

Even though Spielberg’s efforts to hold back the tide rather than riding the wave may be futile, Netflix isn’t without blame here, either. The company has repeatedly bucked industry standards, sometimes rightfully so — the ancient release window of two to three months is laughable in the streaming age.

But in a variety of ways, Netflix has also tried to have its cake and eat it too, playing its awards hopefuls in small-run theaters to simply fulfill a requirement, and spending tens of millions from its seeming endless font of cash on movies like Alfonso Cuaron’s Roma to sway Academy voters, a gambit that paid off with four Oscar wins for the film, including Best Director. According to IndieWire, the money bought near round-the-clock Roma awards parties, streets blanketed in billboards, and promotional gifts like $175 coffee table books, fancy chocolates, and other prizes designed to butter up Academy voters in the lead-up to the victories.

But, of course, so does Netflix

Don’t get me wrong, though. While I love the theater experience, I also love me some Netflix. And though the streamer hasn’t hesitated in its overt efforts to garner awards at (almost literally) any cost, that doesn’t take away from all the good Netflix has done for the world of cinema in recent years.

As any indie filmmaker will tell you, since Netflix’s content boss Ted Sarandos started showering film festivals with big checks, indie filmmaking has seen an incredible renaissance that simply wouldn’t — or couldn’t — have happened in the age of superhero franchise fervor at the theater.

netflix versus spielberg oscars battle future of film ava duvernay gettyAva DuVernay Getty

From mumblecore darlings like the Duplass brothers to important female directors like Ava DuVernay, Netflix has given a voice to an entire generation of filmmakers who simply wouldn’t have had one without it. That’s especially true for women and people of color, who have found in Netflix a creative partner that will let them tell intimate, timely, and culturally important stories that don’t have a home in the current theatrical paradigm. And when it comes to awards like the Oscars and the Golden Globes, aren’t those the kinds of films we should be honoring?

Netflix has given a voice to an entire generation of filmmakers

That’s not to mention the convenience and affordability Netflix offers working-class folks and families, for whom a night out at a quality theater — if there’s even a quality theater within their reach — can come at a cost that’s nearly prohibitive. Netflix allows more people to see more films, more filmmakers to make better films, and more films, in general, to become possible. That’s no small feat, and one worth recognizing and celebrating, not admonishing.

Families gotta compromise

So, is there a way forward here, or will these two warring sides continue to stonewall each other into oblivion? I like to think they can come to amicable terms that will be for the benefit of all filmmakers and film lovers alike — if they can get together and talk.

In a piece I wrote in 2015 about the need for Netflix and the big four theater chains to work together, I offered several possible solutions to this impasse. Those include everything from Netflix agreeing to a longer release window — the four weeks mentioned above sounds like a solid starting point — to mutual profit sharing. Netflix could, for instance, share streaming “profits” on higher-profile releases with theater chains, or cut them in on a wider share of its ticket sales in theaters.

In any event, while Spielberg and company can’t hold back the streaming tide, Netflix can’t navigate the theater world alone, either. As with any happy and productive family, the two sides need to sit down at the table, pour a couple of glasses of wine and talk this thing out. If not for each other, then for us, the kids.

Otherwise, the still-prosperous cinematic landscape as we currently know it could be in trouble for all parties involved. And nobody wants to see a good family break up.

Editors' Recommendations Read More

Leave A Comment

More News

Digital Trends

AMD vs. Intel 2019-03-07 08:00:38When it comes to selecting a CPU for your PC, there's no shortage of chips for you to choose from. With Ryzen, Threadripper, and Core i9 CPUs though,

Just drag and drop: Using A.I., Skylum AirMagic 2019-03-07 08:00:24Drag and drop your drone photos into AirMagic, then go Netflix binge watch while artificial intelligence edits your photos for you. AirMagic is a drag

Digital Trends Live: Foldable phones, an autonomous bus, 2019-03-07 07:34:10On episode 80 of Digital Trends Live, hosts Greg Nibler and Matt Smith broke down the biggest stories from the world of tech, including Samsung's nex

How to split your screen in Windows 10 2019-03-07 07:30:59Windows 10 is a great desktop operating system and its many window management features are part of the reason why. Here's how to divvy up windows usi

How to get Microsoft Office for free 2019-03-07 07:00:35Many of us need to use Office apps from time to time — but we may not want or need to pay for a constant subscription. Fortunately, there are wa

How to take a screenshot on a Chromebook 2019-03-07 06:30:55Chrome OS has a number of built-in screenshot options, and can also be used with Chrome screenshot extensions for added flexibility. You have a lot of

First major 5G network launch delayed over high-price 2019-03-07 06:20:08What was expected to be the world's first working 5G network for the masses has been delayed, over concerns the phones required for it won't be read

Honor Magic 2: News, features, release 2019-03-07 05:19:46The exciting Honor Magic 2 is an almost completely bezel-less smartphone with six camera lenses in total. The front three are revealed in a pop-up sec

Gmail’s handy Smart Compose feature lands on more 2019-03-07 04:15:32Google appears to be rolling out Gmail's handy Smart Compose feature for all Android phones after launching it for desktop and its Pixel handsets las

Don’t fight guys! Netflix v Spielberg and the 2019-03-07 04:00:26As Netflix and Steven Spielberg battle for the future of who goes to the Oscars, there’s a lot more at stake than just some awards ceremony. In

Google Images gets shoppable ads to help you 2019-03-07 02:30:05Following in the footsteps of the likes of Instagram and Pinterest, Google is now testing shoppable ads within image search results that allow you to

All of Amazon’s U.S. pop-up stores are about 2019-03-07 01:45:26Amazon has confirmed that it's closing all of its U.S. pop-up stores. Despite the closures, the company retains a strong interest in brick-and-mortar

Engadget RSS Feed

Nintendo Switch revisited: Two years makes a big 2019-03-07 08:30:00 The Nintendo Switch is no Wii U -- we knew that much when we reviewed it on March 1st, 2017. Its portable design lets you play your games anywhere

Fiat's Centoventi is a customizable EV for the 2019-03-07 08:00:00 Fiat has unveiled a concept EV to promote the idea of a completely customizable car that's available to everyone. The Centoventi, which means "1

Microsoft beats Amazon to open the first cloud 2019-03-07 07:45:00Microsoft has become the first major cloud provider to open a data center in South Africa. Its two new Azure facilities in Cape Town and Johannesburg

The Morning After: Nintendo is bringing VR to 2019-03-07 07:00:00Hey, good morning! Between all the motor show news from Geneva, Mark Zuckerberg is pitching a privacy-focused revamp of Facebook (what would that eve

‘Anthem’ bug makes starter rifle the game’s most 2019-03-07 06:31:00You've gotta pay your dues in shooter game Anthem. Like Destiny 2 and Warframe, you get ahead with tireless grinding, repeatedly working through the

Sony finally brings PS4 Remote Play to iPhone 2019-03-07 05:24:00The latest update to the PlayStation 4 operating system has a feature that some users have craved for years. From today, the console will now properly

Amazon's joint healthcare organization is called 'Haven' 2019-03-07 05:04:00Last year, Amazon announced a healthcare venture with Warren Buffet and JPMorgan Chase. It was still in the planning stages at the time, but now the t

The first­ Spanish­-language esports channel launches in the 2019-03-07 04:05:00Telemundo Deportes has launched the first ever Spanish-language esports streaming channel in the US, showing just how big professional gaming competit

There are only two Blockbusters left in the 2019-03-07 02:55:00And then there was one. A Blockbuster video rental store located in a suburb of Perth Australia announced that it will be closing its doors for good a

Steinway releases high-tech piano that records your performance 2019-03-07 01:41:00Legendary piano maker Steinway & Sons has released a piano that allows musicians to record their own live performances. Each Spirio | r comes

Tesla promises to halve charging time with V3 2019-03-06 23:40:00As promised, Tesla has unveiled the third version of Supercharging, the high-powered chargers that it has spread out to top off owners' batteries as

Google's repair center will finally take your Pixel 2019-03-06 22:53:00Until now, you've had to visit a uBreakiFix location to get your Pixel 3 fixed in an official capacity. That's helpful if you're nearby, but an ab


Roborock E20 Review: An Affordable Robovac You Might 2019-03-07 08:00:00It has a problem with stairs, but this budget robot vacuum and mop offers a lot of bang for your buck.

Best Keyboard Alternatives: Wacom Bamboo, Surface Pen, Dragon 2019-03-07 07:00:00Our writer tests six alternative input methods for users who find it difficult to type on a keyboard.

Fitbit Versa Lite and Fitbit Inspire: Price, Specs, 2019-03-06 09:00:00Instead of competing with Cupertino on features, Fitbit competes on price with a new $160 smartwatch and several new wearable trackers under $100.

How to Use TikTok: Tips for New Users 2019-03-06 07:00:00Step one: turn up the volume on your phone.

Embracing Thunderbolt 3 Will Make Next-Gen USB4 Twice 2019-03-05 11:37:32For years, your dongle life has been a confusing mess. The comingling of USB4 and Thunderbolt 3 will (mostly) fix that for you.

12 Best Android Phones of 2019 (New, Unlocked, 2019-03-05 07:00:00Wonder what the absolute best Android phone is right now? We have the answer, and some alternatives, from Google Pixel to OnePlus to LG and more.

7 Best Baby Carriers (2019): Slings, Wraps, and 2019-03-04 09:00:00The best WIRED-tested wraps, carriers, and slings to help you carry your infant or toddler.

Samsung Galaxy S10 Review: The New Best Android 2019-03-04 08:00:00Samsung's big 2019 flagship Android phones deliver in more ways than you'd think.

Best Cheap PS4 and PS4 Pro Deals and 2019-03-03 08:00:00No matter what game you want to play, these are the best PS4 and accessory deals around.

Want a Foldable Phone? Hold Out for Real 2019-03-03 07:00:00A new wave of smartphones like the Samsung Galaxy Fold use plastic polymers, not glass, for their displays. That could cause some unexpected headaches

12 Best Weekend Tech Deals on iPad, Roomba, 2019-03-02 07:00:00Fight off the winter doldrums with our favorite bargains on everything from robot vacuums to camping gear.

Gadget Lab Podcast: A Deep Dive into Microsoft’s 2019-03-01 15:31:00Microsoft's second-generation mixed reality headset has made a significant leap. Microsoft's Alex Kipman goes into details on the Gadget Lab podcast

Ars Technica » Gear

After the Galaxy Fold, Samsung has two more 2019-03-06 14:21:32Samsung is developing a Mate X-style wraparound display phone and a flip phone.

Microsoft is first major cloud provider to open 2019-03-06 12:07:04Cape Town, Johannesburg cloud regions now available.

iFixit opens up the Galaxy S10, revealing tiny 2019-03-06 10:58:25Get a look at Qualcomm's new ultrasonic fingerprint sensor in the S10.

Apple no longer refuses to fix iPhones with 2019-03-06 09:45:41Now Genius Bars and Authorized Service Providers won't turn these iPhones away.

Fitbit goes after new wrists with less expensive 2019-03-06 09:00:44Fitbit wants more users on its platform—that means devices at many price points.

Gorilla Glass-maker plans to produce glass suitable for 2019-03-05 20:30:12Glass would be more durable than the plastic polymers used in early foldables.

Chromium-based Edge screenshots might as well be Chrome 2019-03-05 11:54:30It's early days yet, but so far Microsoft has done little to distinguish its browser.

After Roma swept the Oscars, Steven Spielberg seeks 2019-03-04 17:55:22Spielberg feels that films like Roma should be classified as TV movies instead.

Google temporarily shuts down Android TV photo sharing 2019-03-04 13:04:07A user was apparently able to see hundreds of Google Photo accounts.

Get your first look at the OnePlus 7 2019-03-04 11:55:01Who needs a notch when you can just make the camera disappear into the phone?

Thunderbolt 3 becomes USB4, as Intel’s interconnect goes 2019-03-04 11:32:07Intel makes good on its 2017 promise; the USB-IF is still terrible at naming things.

Mini-review: 24 hours with Dell’s fanciest Chromebook yet 2019-03-03 10:30:59At $599 and 3.9 pounds, this Chrome OS convertible has clear pros and cons.

TechCrunch » Gadgets

Sonos refreshes Sonos One with better components 2019-03-06 15:46:58Sonos is launching the most minor of minor updates. The company is launching a revision to its flagship speaker, the Sonos One. Sonos is calling this

IDC: Apple led wearables market in 2018, with 2019-03-05 12:23:33Apple devices continue to lead the wearables market, according to a new report from IDC out today, which claimed the Cupertino-based company shipped a

You can now ask Alexa to control your 2019-03-05 09:00:04Roku this morning announced its devices will now be compatible with Amazon’s Alexa. Through a new Roku skill for Alexa, Roku owners will be able

Galaxy S10 takes the ‘best smartphone display’ crown 2019-03-04 14:05:42As you may have gathered from our review of Samsung's Galaxy S10, it's a very solid phone with lots of advanced features. But one thing that's espe

Outdoor Tech’s Chips ski helmet speakers are a 2019-03-04 13:53:18Sometimes the “smartest” gadgets come with the shoddiest security. Alan Monie, a security researcher at U.K. cybersecurity firm Pen Test P

With USB 4, Thunderbolt and USB will converge 2019-03-04 10:47:01Your cable nightmare might soon be over. The USB Implementers Forum (USB-IF) has unveiled the specifications of USB 4.0, as Engadget reports. And USB

Koala-sensing drone helps keep tabs on drop bear 2019-03-01 19:33:39It's obviously important to Australians to make sure their koala population is closely tracked — but how can you do so when the suckers live in

SpaceX’s Crew Dragon makes its first orbital launch 2019-03-01 13:51:25After years of development and delays, SpaceX's Crew Dragon is ready to launch into orbit. It's the first commercially built and operated crewed spa

Amazon stops selling stick-on Dash buttons 2019-03-01 05:56:59Amazon has confirmed it has retired physical stick-on Dash buttons from sale — in favor of virtual alternatives that let Prime Members tap a dig

OneWeb’s first six global internet satellites are safely 2019-02-27 15:00:22After four years and more than $2 billion in funding, OneWeb is ready to launch the first six satellites out of a planned constellation of 650 with wh

Pokémon Sword and Shield to land on Nintendo 2019-02-27 10:52:55Nintendo and The Pokémon Company have unveiled the next Pokémon game in the main series. The new game will come in two variants later th

The Shadow Ghost turns cloud gaming into a 2019-02-27 10:01:59French startup Blade, the company behind Shadow, is launching a new set-top box to access its cloud gaming service — the Shadow Ghost. I’v

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.