• Follow us


Tesla Model Y Styling Breakdown: A Designer's Take on the New SUV - MotorTrend

KR: At the Model Y's introduction, our Miguel Cortina got a ride in one that has the optional third row, but they wouldn't let anybody climb back there. Third row—good or bad?

TG: I think it's a waste of time. The compromise to overall storage space is a step too far.

KR: So far, you're being critical.

TG: Actually, you really can't fault the car's line work, and I think the Model Y sits on the platform fairly well. They've used some of the devices they did on the Model X, where you black out things they don't on the sedans. And when you look at the way the Model Y's DLO [daylight opening—the shape of the side glass] finishes within the side view, it's far more comfortable than on Model X, where it hangs on for so long the car almost looked shifted on its platform.

KR: I'm sensing a "but" coming …

TG: I would have loved to have seen them exercise their design talent trying to figure out a roof that's better suited to the intended function of this vehicle. I love the design consistency, but I can see the internal struggles that they must be having. I just would've let this one break out and say, "See, we can go after this market with some different stuff."

KR: When I look at the Model Y's profile, what I see is the price of batteries talking. It's pack probably costs $10,000-plus, meaning—unlike a gasoline car—the Model Y has to be obsessively efficient to minimize this tremendously expensive cost. Probably why Lucid's first car, the Air, is an aerodynamic sedan, too. And why I'm sort of amazed by the boxy Rivian. But on the other hand, the Rivian is exactly what people expect a crossover or truck to look like.

TG: I'm no longer on Rivian's board, but I'll tell you that it's far more efficient than it looks. Look—this is the designer in me talking so take it with a grain of salt—I wouldn't compromise for a few minuscule points of aero. As important as they are, you're going to throw the baby away with the bath water because the public's consideration is the most important thing. Without knowing any of the aero numbers, but being taller, you've already got the frontal area. And there's a lot of aero devices you could use if the roofline had a conventional pickup in the back. OK, you're going to create a larger vortex, but I would question how much of that offsets what you're losing in terms of the product perception. That's the central point: If the reason's aero, that's a big bet. Look at the BMW X6 or the Honda Crosstour. Not very well accepted...

KR: So let's imagine that you walk into Tesla design studio just at the point where the Model Y was a full-scale, completed clay model. I hand you the sculpting tools to make changes. What would you do?

TG: Well, that's tough because Franz [von Holzhausen, Tesla's chief designer] is living with it day-in and day-out. And I think the openings, the graphics of the vehicle overall, the line work of the vehicle, it's really very good. But if I were to lead them, I guess I would say, "I want to investigate what you could do with the roofline and still have it be Tesla." Leave the C-pillar—that is very recognizable of Tesla—and then try to grow something out of the back of it. Then I would look at whether there's an inventive way to change what you do with the hatch to gain function. Maybe you let some of the top of the hatch move forward into the roof so that you've got a taller space to hold stuff.

KR: Go on. You're on a roll.

TG: From there I would move around to the front and say, "Why don't we look for a way to create some image equity that would be ours. Maybe make the top of the Tesla 'T' part of the upper character line." They kind of started it already with the noses of the Model S and X. Then I'd ask, "Is there something we can do to accentuate its capabilities?" I would've loved to have seen a little bit more track—maybe they could've done it with wheel offset. I would've been really riding hard on the engineering guys for me.

KR: Back to the roofline; instead of the Y's big slope, could Tesla have gone with the sort of station wagon-y roofline of the Porsche Gran Turismos?

View 7 Photos

TG: For some reason, the words "station wagon" are verboten in the U.S. Having said that, I think the Gran Turismos are very successful from a design perspective. But from a marketing perspective, station wagons are too low to be perceived as functional.

KR: Earlier, I Googled images of the Model Y, and at first glance, I didn't realize that a lot of them were speculative renderings made before the unveiling. You can hardly tell them from the actual car. This must be the most predictable-looking vehicle in a long time. And with its sloping roofline, it's dangerously undifferentiated from the Model 3.

TG: I think they're going to cannibalize some Model 3 sales.

KR: A lot rides on Tesla making the case—without advertising; they don't advertise—that the Y isn't just a "Model 3 Tall (M3T?)" but instead a new-think aerodynamic crossover. I guess we'll see, right Tom?

TG: I guess we will.

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News


Electric Buses, Quiet Tires, and More Car News 2019-06-09 09:00:00Why haven't electric buses caught on? And how does Mattel shrink car designs to make Hot Wheels?

Lyft's Lawsuit Against San Francisco Is Bigger Than 2019-06-07 18:28:35Lyft's bike-share company, Motivate, had an exclusive contract with the city for its docked bike program. But if San Francisco allows a dockless bike

Why Electric Buses Haven't Taken Over the World—Yet 2019-06-07 09:48:28Here’s what stands between you and a cleaner commute.

This Startup Wants to Remake the Last Mile 2019-06-06 09:00:00Boxbot is building self-driving delivery vans, plus an automatic loading system. Humans would still help when needed to open gates or climb stairs.

Bridgestone’s Turanza QuietTrack Tire Silences Electric Cars 2019-06-05 07:00:00The new rubber has specially designed threads to hush the pesky "pattern noise" that's especially noticeable in cars without loud engines.

How Mattel Shrinks Cars Into Hot Wheels (Crash 2019-06-04 07:00:00Before a Hot Wheels car hits a store shelf, it must pass the "launcher on speed 2" test, and the "side slam launcher" test, among others.

What a Bay Area Dispute Says About the 2019-06-03 07:00:00Lyft's Motivate has exclusive bike-share contracts with several cities. San Francisco officials are debating what "exclusive" means.

Hybrid Ferraris! Flying Cars! And More Car News 2019-06-02 09:00:00Plus: You can now pay for some NYC subway rides with your iPhone, but the system is about more than just fast taps.

New York Transit Edges Into a Future Without 2019-05-31 07:00:00Beginning Friday, you can get into select subway stations by waving your phone. By 2023, MetroCards will go the way of the token.

Ferrari’s 986-HP Hybrid, Disney’s Message to Georgia, and 2019-05-30 19:32:10Catch up on the most important news from today in two minutes or less.

Flying Car Startup Alaka'i Bets Hydrogen Outdoes Batteries 2019-05-30 13:53:20The new aviation player is showing off a boxy electric six-rotor air taxi powered by hydrogen fuel cells.

Ferrari’s Latest Goes 211 MPH With 986 HP—and 2019-05-30 08:00:00The SF90 Stradale is Ferrari’s most powerful production vehicle: a plug-in hybrid electric that goes 0 to 62 mph in 2.5 seconds.

Automotive News Breaking

How do global suppliers thrive in a tough 2019-06-10 14:56:34There are many great examples of how innovation keeps big auto suppliers healthy, but a smaller, lesser-known supplier named Kiekert offers another ki

Automotive journalist disappears on motorcycle trip 2019-06-10 14:49:15Davey Johnson rode a black Honda CB100R on Highway 108, which police found parked with his helmet and gloves Saturday at Big Bar River Access on the N

Audi recalls 2020 e-tron over potentially faulty grommet 2019-06-10 13:00:43Audi of America is voluntarily recalling its new e-tron battery electric vehicle, which went on sale in April in the U.S., to replace a wiring grommet

Trump resumes tariff threats against China and Mexico 2019-06-10 12:53:33Trump's Monday morning tweets follow his announcement last week that the United States and Mexico reached a signed migration agreement. He also renew

Tesla employees' morale suffers amid cost-cutting, layoffs 2019-06-10 12:19:14Tesla placed 16th on LinkedIn's annual "Top Companies 2019" list published in April, compiled from billions of actions taken by its over 600 millio

Ford launches ad campaign for FordPass app 2019-06-10 11:23:35The mobile app, formally launched April 2, allows customers to monitor vehicles and make service appointments.

Nissan CEO got higher stock-linked bonus after payout 2019-06-10 07:10:56In his first interview since his arrest for alleged financial misconduct, Greg Kelly said Hiroto Saikawa was due to get a stock appreciation rights pa

Wells Fargo agrees to pay customers $386M over 2019-06-10 06:37:29The settlement covers class-action claims that Wells Fargo signed customers up for unwanted or unneeded auto insurance policies when they took out car

FCA-Renault revival may hinge on Nissan stake cut, 2019-06-10 06:24:10Nissan is poised to urge Renault to significantly reduce its 43.4 percent stake in the Japanese company in return for supporting a FCA-Renault ti

Ghosn lawyers hit back at audit showing millions 2019-06-10 04:13:19Ghosn's French lawyers say Renault compiled the audit without getting his input or response to the allegations.

FCA reeling after failed tie-up, suit by Bigland 2019-06-10 00:00:01Just when it seemed Fiat Chrysler was on a clear path forward, the automaker pulled the plug on a merger with Renault and was sued by its own U.S. sal

FCA partners with Aurora on self-driving tech 2019-06-10 00:00:01The two companies will work together to develop and deploy autonomous technology on commercial vehicles.

Motor Trend

2020 Ram 1500 EcoDiesel Boasts 480 LB-FT, HUGE 2019-06-10 10:00:34It’s Ram vs. Ford vs. Chevy all over again, diesel-style. The 2020 Ram 1500 EcoDiesel bursts back onto the full-size diesel truck scene with som

2019 Volkswagen Arteon Interior Review: 6 Key Details 2019-06-10 04:03:29If you’re looking for a car more versatile than a typical sedan but don’t want a crossover, your choices are limited, especially if it mus

Are the Best BMWs Now Super-Sized SUVs? – 2019-06-10 04:02:54Just prior to shipping the August 2019 print issue, the only two BMWs I had recently driven were the X7 and X5—both all-new for 2019. I had only

Here are the Safest Small Cars in 2019 2019-06-10 04:00:39Just because your car is small doesn’t mean you have to sacrifice safety. Thanks to technological advancements, small cars are safer than ever.

2019 Honda Passport: Why I’d Buy It – 2019-06-10 04:00:36“What SUV should I buy?” It’s a question consumers ask themselves every day, but what would associate online editor Alex Leanse driv

BMW 3 Series vs. Alfa Romeo Giulia Comparison: 2019-06-10 04:00:27For decades, the BMW 3 Series was the epitome of the luxury sport sedan. Its great handling, punchy power, and dynamic ride made it the leader of its

Fellow Auto Journalist Davey G. Johnson Is Missing 2019-06-09 21:11:06Davey G. Johnson, our friend and colleague, is missing. He was last heard from early Wednesday morning while riding along the Sonora Pass in Californi

2019 Subaru Crosstrek Limited: Why I’d Buy It 2019-06-08 04:00:46“What SUV should I buy?” It’s a question consumers ask themselves every day, but what would associate online editor Collin Woodard d

2020 Mercedes-Benz GLC 300 and GLC 63 Review: 2019-06-07 18:01:26Midcycle product updates are tricky. Capital is typically limited, so you can’t do much with the sheetmetal or engineering bits. But you need yo

The Hottest Wheels From the Hot Wheels Legends 2019-06-07 17:48:45We took a trip to Charlotte, North Carolina, over Memorial Day weekend for the sixth stop on the 2019 Hot Wheels Legends Tour—a series of 18 uni

What SUV Should I Buy? MotorTrend Editors Pick 2019-05-30 04:00:45From Blazer to Bentayga, MotorTrend drives and actually tests hundreds of SUVs every year–and now it’s our turn to share our personal favo

2019 Subaru Forester: Why I’d Buy It – 2019-05-30 04:00:07“What SUV should I buy?” It’s a question consumers ask themselves every day, but what would online editor Kelly Pleskot drive? Keep

Automotive news - from

Renault rift with Nissan widens 2019-06-10 09:07:00Despite some hope the withdrawn proposal for a merger between Fiat-Chrysler (FCA) and Renault could be revived if a way can be found to alleviate Rena

West European car demand flat in May 2019-06-10 08:28:00West European new car sales fell slightly - by 0.3% year-on-year (YoY) in May, according to data released by LMC Automotive. The annualised selling ra

Hyundai Mobis launches start-up centre in Shenzhen, China 2019-06-10 08:27:00Hyundai Mobis has announced the launch of 'M Cube' in China's Shenzhen, an innovation centre for Chinese start-ups.

Denso to open Technical Training Centre at Michigan 2019-06-10 08:25:00Denso has invested US$1.95m in the North Technical Training Centre at its Battle Creek, Michigan, facility.

EVgo and Chevron team on filling station chargers 2019-06-10 08:03:00Evgo is working with Chevron to bring EV fast charging to Chevron company-owned and operated petrol stations in California.

SAIC targets Japanese automakers in Philippines 2019-06-10 07:58:00Chinese automaker SAIC Motor is moving to undercut Japanese rivals in the Philippines, one of southeast Asia's fastest-growing economies, a media rep

Plugsurfing and Kia team for Europe EV charger 2019-06-10 07:16:00Plugsurfing and Kia Motors Netherlands are to provide a Europe-wide solution for all Kia electric vehicle drivers.

FCA-Renault merger revival possible - report 2019-06-10 07:14:00A withdrawn proposal for a merger between Fiat-Chrysler (FCA) and Renault could be revived if a way can be found to alleviate Renault's alliance part

Trump lifts Mexico tariff threat for now 2019-06-10 06:59:00After the US and Mexico reached an agreement late on Friday to stave off tariffs on Mexican goods in return for concessions on immigration, Donald Tru

Toyota partners with CATL, BYD to meet new 2019-06-10 06:19:00Toyota Motor announced it was joining forces with Chinese battery manufacturers Contemporary Amperex Technology Limited (CATL) and BYD Auto to increas

Japan to raise fuel-efficiency target by 32% in 2019-06-10 06:04:00The Japanese government plans to introduce new regulations in the 2030 fiscal year (FY2030) requiring automakers to improve average fuel efficienc

Renault/Nissan team on Tel Aviv start-up lab 2019-06-10 05:43:00Renault and Nissan have inaugurated a new facility for a joint innovation laboratory in Atidim Park, Tel Aviv, to allow which the Alliance to accelera

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.