• Follow us

Social Media

Libra, Facebook’s global digital currency plan, is fuzzy on privacy, watchdogs warn – TechCrunch

Privacy commissioners from the Americas, Europe, Africa and Australasia have put their names to a joint statement raising concerns about a lack of clarity from Facebook over how data protection safeguards will be baked into its planned cryptocurrency project, Libra.

Facebook officially unveiled its big bet to build a global digital currency using blockchain technology in June, steered by a Libra Association with Facebook as a founding member. Other founding members include payment and tech giants such as Mastercard, PayPal, Uber, Lyft, eBay; VC firms including Andreessen Horowitz, Thrive Capital and Union Square Ventures; and not-for-profits such as Kiva and Mercy Corps.

At the same time, Facebook announced a new subsidiary of its own business, Calibra, which it said will create financial services for the Libra network, including offering a standalone wallet app that it expects to bake into its messaging apps, Messenger and WhatsApp, next year — raising concerns it could quickly gain a monopolistic hold over what’s being couched as an “open” digital currency network, given the dominance of the associated social platforms where it intends to seed its own wallet.

In its official blog post hyping Calibra, Facebook avoided any talk of how much market power it might wield via its ability to promote the wallet to its existing 2.2 billion+ global users, but it did touch on privacy — writing “we’ll also take steps to protect your privacy” by claiming it would not share “account information or financial data with Facebook or any third party without customer consent.”

Except for when it admitted it would; the same paragraph states there will be “limited cases” when it may share user data. These cases will “reflect our need to keep people safe, comply with the law and provide basic functionality to the people who use Calibra,” the blog adds. (A Calibra Customer Commitment provides little more detail than a few sample instances, such as “preventing fraud and criminal activity.”)

All of that might sound reassuring enough on the surface, but Facebook has used the fuzzy notion of needing to keep its users “safe” as an umbrella justification for tracking non-Facebook users across the entire mainstream internet, for example.

So the devil really is in the granular detail of anything the company claims it will and won’t do.

Hence the lack of comprehensive details about Libra’s approach to privacy and data protection is causing professional watchdogs around the world to worry.

“As representatives of the global community of data protection and privacy enforcement authorities, collectively responsible for promoting the privacy of many millions of people around the world, we are joining together to express our shared concerns about the privacy risks posed by the Libra digital currency and infrastructure,” they write. “Other authorities and democratic lawmakers have expressed concerns about this initiative. These risks are not limited to financial privacy, since the involvement of Facebook Inc., and its expansive categories of data collection on hundreds of millions of users, raises additional concerns. Data protection authorities will also work closely with other regulators.”

Among the commissioners signing the statement is the FTC’s Rohit Chopra, one of two commissioners at the U.S. Federal Trade Commission who dissented from the $5 billion settlement order that was passed by a 3:2 vote last month. 

Also raising concerns about Facebook’s transparency about how Libra will comply with privacy laws and expectations in multiple jurisdictions around the world are: Canada’s privacy commissioner Daniel Therrien; the European Union’s data protection supervisor, Giovanni Buttarelli; U.K. Information commissioner, Elizabeth Denham; Albania’s information and data protection commissioner, Besnik Dervishi; the president of the Commission for Information Technology and Civil Liberties for Burkina Faso, Marguerite Ouedraogo Bonane; and Australia’s information and privacy commissioner, Angelene Falk.

In the joint statement — on what they describe as “global privacy expectations of the Libra network” — they write:

In today’s digital age, it is critical that organisations are transparent and accountable for their personal information handling practices. Good privacy governance and privacy by design are key enablers for innovation and protecting data – they are not mutually exclusive. To date, while Facebook and Calibra have made broad public statements about privacy, they have failed to specifically address the information handling practices that will be in place to secure and protect personal information. Additionally, given the current plans for a rapid implementation of Libra and Calibra, we are surprised and concerned that this further detail is not yet available. The involvement of Facebook Inc. as a founding member of the Libra Association has the potential to drive rapid uptake by consumers around the globe, including in countries which may not yet have data protection laws in place. Once the Libra Network goes live, it may instantly become the custodian of millions of people’s personal information. This combination of vast reserves of personal information with financial information and cryptocurrency amplifies our privacy concerns about the Libra Network’s design and data sharing arrangements.

We’ve pasted below the list of questions they’re putting to the Libra Network — which they specify is “non-exhaustive,” saying individual agencies may follow up with more “as the proposals and service offering develops.”

Among the details they’re seeking answers to is clarity on what users’ personal data will be used for and how users will be able to control what their data is used for.

The risk of dark patterns being used to weaken and undermine users’ privacy is another stated concern.

Where user data is shared the commissioners are also seeking clarity on the types of data and the de-identification techniques that will be used — on the latter researchers have demonstrated for years that just a handful of data points can be used to re-identify credit card users from an “anonymous” data set of transactions, for example.

Here’s the full list of questions being put to the Libra Network:

1. How can global data protection and privacy enforcement authorities be confident that the Libra Network has robust measures to protect the personal information of network users? In particular, how will the Libra Network ensure that its participants will:

a. provide clear information about how personal information will be used (including the use of profiling and algorithms, and the sharing of personal information between members of the Libra Network and any third parties) to allow users to provide specific and informed consent where appropriate; b. create privacy-protective default settings that do not use nudge techniques or “dark patterns” to encourage people to share personal data with third parties or weaken their privacy protections; c. ensure that privacy control settings are prominent and easy to use; d. collect and process only the minimum amount of personal information necessary to achieve the identified purpose of the product or service, and ensure the lawfulness of the processing; e. ensure that all personal data is adequately protected; and f. give people simple procedures for exercising their privacy rights, including deleting their accounts, and honouring their requests in a timely way.

2. How will the Libra Network incorporate privacy by design principles in the development of its infrastructure?

3. How will the Libra Association ensure that all processors of data within the Libra Network are identified, and are compliant with their respective data protection obligations?

4. How does the Libra Network plan to undertake data protection impact assessments, and how will the Libra Network ensure these assessments are considered on an ongoing basis?

5. How will the Libra Network ensure that its data protection and privacy policies, standards and controls apply consistently across the Libra Network’s operations in all jurisdictions?

6. Where data is shared amongst Libra Network members:

a. what data elements will be involved?

b. to what extent will it be de-identified, and what method will be used to achieve de-identification?c. how will Libra Network ensure that data is not re-identified, including by use of enforceable contractual commitments with those with whom data is shared?

We’ve reached out to Facebook for comment.

Update: A Facebook spokesperson sent this statement, attributed to Dante Disparte of the Libra Association:

We appreciate these thoughtful questions and share the commitment to protecting personal information. As much as Libra represents an opportunity for the world to make inroads on financial inclusion, we acknowledge the need to design an infrastructure that complies with global privacy requirements.

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News

TechCrunch » Social

Pew: Mobile and social media users in emerging 2019-08-22 13:56:26The latest study from Pew Research Center takes a look at the impact mobile technology, including the use of smartphones and social media, is having o

Tumblr’s next step forward with Automattic CEO Matt 2019-08-22 13:37:18After months of rumors, Verizon finally sold off Tumblr for a reported $3 million — a fraction of what Yahoo paid for the once mighty blogging s

Twitter picks up team from narrative app Lightwell 2019-08-21 13:24:59Twitter’s ongoing, long-term efforts to make conversations easier to follow and engage with on its platform is getting a boost with the company&

YouTube is closing its private messages feature…and many 2019-08-21 10:12:37People love to share YouTube videos among their friends, which is why in mid-2017 YouTube launched a new in-app messaging feature that would allow You

‘This is Your Life in Silicon Valley’: The 2019-08-20 12:04:14This edition features Amanda Bradford - Founder/CEO of The League. Amanda talks about modern dating, its limitations, why 'The League' will win, and

Facebook unveils new tools to control how websites 2019-08-20 11:00:29Last year, Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg announced that the company would be creating a “Clear History” feature that deletes the data that

Twitter blocks state-controlled media outlets from advertising on 2019-08-19 15:37:56Twitter is now blocking state-run media outlets from advertising on its platform. The new policy was announced just hours after the company identified

Twitter to test a new filter for spam 2019-08-16 11:35:49Twitter is testing a new way to filter unwanted messages from your Direct Message inbox. Today, Twitter allows users to set their Direct Message inbox

Twitter leads $100M round in top Indian regional 2019-08-15 21:30:10Is there room for another social media platform? ShareChat, a four-year-old social network in India that serves tens of million of people in regional

US legislator, David Cicilline, joins international push to 2019-08-15 12:28:22US legislator David Cicilline will be joining the next meeting of the International Grand Committee on Disinformation and ‘Fake News’, it

What will Tumblr become under the ownership of 2019-08-15 12:03:50This week, Automattic revealed it has signed all the paperwork to acquire Tumblr from Verizon, including its full staff of 200. Tumblr has undergone q

Instagram says growth hackers are behind spate of 2019-08-15 09:53:42If you use Instagram and have noticed a bunch of strangers watching your Stories in recent months — accounts that don’t follow you and see


We went to the 'Telling Lies' set and 2019-08-23 14:06:28The language doesn't exist yet to describe (or even accurately categorize) what Sam Barlow is making. Which is probably why all our conversations, bo

Rivian teases new electric truck and camping-friendly tent 2019-08-23 14:00:00The company plans to showcase the truck soon, with potential consumers speculate about the truck's cost. Read more...More about Transportation, Masha

Here's what’s leaving Netflix in September 2019-08-23 13:45:00The titles include Disney films, a few series, and a "Superman" classic. Read more...More about Entertainment, Movies, Netflix, Mashable Video, and

Internet users lost over $6 million through Nigerian 2019-08-23 13:30:00The FBI recently unsealed the case, revealing that almost $40 million was at stake of being stolen through these scams. Read more...More about Tech, M

Apple shares rigorous instructions for Apple Card maintenance, 2019-08-23 13:15:03The card, released Aug. 20, has been met with some skepticism and humor after Apple revealed what seemed to be an extensive care plan for the card. Re

iPhone 11 may come with Apple Pencil support 2019-08-23 13:12:05With an accessory being created to hold an Apple Pencil, this may decrease the discrepancy of Apple and its competitors, while increasing competition.

It's time to watch the beluga cam 2019-08-23 13:07:23They sound like cosmic radio transmissions, sent from another solar system, or galaxy.  But no, these resonating squeaks and whistles are emanati

Mark Zuckerberg invented this smart alarm clock for 2019-08-23 12:38:26The Facebook titan came up with the idea after his wife, Priscilla, couldn't sleep. Read more...More about Tech, Mashable Video, Mark Zuckerberg, Ala

Tom Brady simply can't pull off this hat 2019-08-23 12:19:13Tom Brady is no Diane Keaton, that's for damn sure. Obviously, he is not an iconic, award-winning actress, director, or producer. But he is also not

Subway riders befriended a cute little bug on 2019-08-23 12:03:12Bugs on the New York City subway system rarely get the star treatment, but one lucky insect got vaulted to fame on Thursday when passengers discovered

Best TV deals for the weekend of Aug. 2019-08-23 11:40:27Many people were surprised about how long it took the media to speak up about the Amazon rainforest fires — and there's a lot of other stu

"No Man’s Sky" provides a soulful antidote to 2019-08-23 11:22:20Ad content by Hello Games Open up any newspaper, listen to any current events podcast, stream any pundit’s YouTube channel, and you’ll see

The Next Web

Google plays politics with China as it quietly 2019-08-23 14:47:31Google yesterday announced it’d banned 210 YouTube accounts “related to the ongoing protests in Hong Kong” and the discovery was &ld

GOG Galaxy 2.0 beats all the other PC 2019-08-23 14:36:31GOG, that other gaming platform, created a new launcher specifically to help everyone get all their games in one place. I finally tried it,

Why reCAPTCHA is actually an act of human 2019-08-23 10:53:57Like many things that start out as a mere annoyance, though eventually grow into somewhat of an affliction. One particular dark and insidious thing ha

Why Minecraft and Mixer are the perfect streaming 2019-08-23 10:03:03I feel I should start by explaining that I am brand new to any form of streaming. I have played Minecraft a fair amount, albeit five years ago and a l

Hacker who sold Uber’s and Sainsbury’s customer data 2019-08-23 10:01:10A hacker has been ordered to pay back over $1.1 million (£900,000) in cryptocurrency after carrying out attacks on several well-known busin

AWS issues are causing erratic cryptocurrency market data 2019-08-23 08:55:13Cryptocurrency exchanges are reportedly experiencing some disruption – how the tables have turned – after an outage at Amazon’s Web

Indian court rejects the idea of linking social 2019-08-23 08:51:20Earlier this week, The Madras High Court in India ruled against any possibility of linking Aadhaar or any government ID with social media accounts. Ju

Hackers behind Texas ransomware attacks want $2.5 million 2019-08-23 08:22:22The threat actor behind the coordinated ransomware attack against multiple Texas local governments may have gained access to its computer systems

Meet the data connection device that works globally—and 2019-08-23 08:00:00The Tern Global Data Connection Device is the only device that allows you to stay connected anywhere in the world. Right now, this offer from TNW

Facebook’s ‘cryptocurrency’ Libra may be in more trouble 2019-08-23 07:41:50Facebook‘s ‘cryptocurrency’ Libra may be in even deeper trouble than we thought if a recent report is anything to go by. According t

55% of mobile phone users plan to keep 2019-08-22 19:39:03A new study shows confirms the worst fears of mobile phone manufacturers like Apple and Samsung. According to responses from 3,640 mobile phone users

iPhone 11 Pro: Everything we think we know 2019-08-22 19:31:00If Apple sticks to its usual timing, it should reveal its latest iPhones in a manner of weeks. But as always, the rumor mill has churned out enough le


Free Webinar: How Mobility Is Revolutionizing Transportation and 2019-08-22 16:46:03Are you ready to start a business in the fast-moving mobility industry?

Why Execution Is More Important Than Strategy 2019-08-22 15:57:00Good ideas are only half the battle. Strategy means nothing if you don't execute.

The Real Reason Sales and Marketing Teams Use 2019-08-22 14:30:00How artificial intelligence can make your team more human.

How to Get the Most Out of Your 2019-08-22 13:30:00Eric Siu discusses some of his tips and tricks to try on the social media platform.

7 Strategies to Keep Making Money Under Any 2019-08-22 12:30:00These tips can help your business survive hard times.

How to Excel at Work Even If You 2019-08-22 12:15:00It's the only true cure for a case of the Mondays.

Apple Is Expected to Launch 3 New iPhones 2019-08-22 12:13:50Potential changes include a new three-lens camera system and the ability to use the iPhone as a charging pad for other products.

How Agile Leaders Help Organizations Thrive 2019-08-22 11:15:00They're best suited to understand the dynamics of surviving and thriving amid organizational headwinds

The Importance of Hiring the Very Best Instead 2019-08-22 10:30:00To find the best employees, make sure that you take the time to implement a successful hiring process.

6 Ways to Use Instagram to Boost Your 2019-08-22 10:21:48In her role at Adobe, Veronica Belmont works to help people bring their ideas to the masses on social media. One of her tips: Create a content calenda

Is It Time for a Financial Stress Test? 2019-08-22 10:02:00Unsure about your financial wealth planning? Consider a stress test.

A DNA Testing Kit That Tackles Your Health 2019-08-22 09:30:00DNA-based probiotics might help you feel better and think quicker on your feet.

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.