• Follow us

Social Media

Facebook can be told to cast a wider net to find illegal content, says EU court advisor – TechCrunch

How much of an obligation should social media platforms be under to hunt down illegal content?

An influential advisor to Europe’s top court has taken the view that social media platforms like Facebook can be required to seek out and identify posts that are equivalent to content that an EU court has deemed illegal — such as hate speech or defamation — if the comments have been made by the same user.

Platforms can also be ordered to hunt for identical repostings of the illegal content.

But there should not be an obligation for platforms to identify equivalent defamatory comments that have been posted by any user, with the advocate general opining that such a broad requirement would not ensure a fair balance between the fundamental rights concerned — flagging risks to free expression and free access to information.

“An obligation to identify equivalent information originating from any user would not ensure a fair balance between the fundamental rights concerned. On the one hand, seeking and identifying such information would require costly solutions. On the other hand, the implementation of those solutions would lead to censorship, so that freedom of expression and information might well be systematically restricted.”

We covered this referral to the CJEU last year.

It’s an interesting case that blends questions of hate speech moderation and the limits of robust political speech, given that the original 2016 complaint of defamation was made by the former leader of the Austrian Green Party, Eva Glawischnig.

An Austrian court agreed with Glawischnig that hate speech posts made about her on Facebook were defamatory and ordered the company to remove them. Facebook did so, but only in Austria. Glawischnig challenged its partial takedown and in May 2017 a local appeals court ruled that it must remove both the original posts and any verbatim repostings and do so worldwide, not just in Austria. 

Further legal appeals led to the referral to the CJEU which is being asked to determine where the line should be drawn for similarly defamatory postings, and whether takedowns can be applied globally or only locally.

On the global takedowns point, the advocate general believes that existing EU law does not present an absolute blocker to social media platforms being ordered to remove information worldwide.

“Both the question of the extraterritorial effects of an injunction imposing a removal obligation and the question of the territorial scope of such an obligation should be analysed, in particular, by reference to public and private international law,” runs the non-binding opinion.

Another element relates to the requirement under existing EU law that platforms should not be required to carry out general monitoring of information they store — and specifically whether that directive precludes platforms from being ordered to remove “information equivalent to the information characterised as illegal” when they have been made aware of it by the person concerned, third parties or another source. 

On that, the AG takes the view that the EU’s e-Commerce Directive does not prevent platforms from being ordered to take down equivalent illegal content when it’s been flagged to them by others — writing that, in that case, “the removal obligation does not entail general monitoring of information stored”.

Advocate General Maciej Szpunar’s opinion — which can be read in full here — is not the last word on the matter, with the court still to deliberate and issue its final decision (usually within three to six months of an AG opinion). However advisors to the CJEU are influential and tend to predict which way the court will jump.

We reached out to Facebook for comment. A spokesperson for the company told us:

This case raises important questions about freedom of expression online and about the role that internet platforms should play in locating and removing speech, particularly when it comes to political discussions and criticizing elected officials. We remove content that breaks the law and our priority is always to keep people on Facebook safe. However this opinion undermines the long-standing principle that one country should not have the right to limit free expression in other countries. We hope the CJEU will clarify that, even in the age of the internet, the scope of court orders from one country must be limited to its borders.

This report was updated with comment from Facebook

Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

TechCrunch » Social

Amazon Spark, the retailer’s two-year-old Instagram competitor, has 2019-06-14 20:18:20Amazon’s two-year-old Instagram competitor, Amazon Spark, is no more. Hoping to capitalize on the social shopping trend and tap into the power o

Calendar influencers? Event social network IRL raises $8M 2019-06-13 11:20:55Why is there no app where you can follow party animals, concert snobs or conference butterflies for their curated suggestions of events? That’s

Facebook backs social commerce startup Meesho in first 2019-06-13 07:31:49As Facebook explores ways to generate revenue from WhatsApp, the company is now turning to a startup that already has a lead. The social juggernaut sa

Facebook collected device data on 187,000 users using 2019-06-12 17:09:43Facebook obtained personal and sensitive device data on about 187,000 users of its now-defunct Research app, which Apple banned earlier this year afte

Facebook’s Blood Donations feature arrives in US, will 2019-06-12 10:15:08Facebook today is expanding its set of features focused on blood donations. The company since 2017 has been working with blood donation centers worldw

Fortnite maker Epic acquires social video app Houseparty 2019-06-12 10:08:34What does a gaming company do after raising $1.25 billion? Acquisitions seem like a pretty good place to start. Epic Games — of Unreal Engine an

WhatsApp is finally going after outside firms that 2019-06-11 15:56:30WhatsApp has so far relied on past dealings with bad players within its platform to ramp up its efforts to curtail spam and other automated behavior.

Dropbox relaunches as an enterprise collaboration workspace 2019-06-11 13:19:37Dropbox is evolving from a file-storage system to an enterprise software portal, where you can coordinate work with your team. Today the company launc

Facebook’s new Study app pays adults for data 2019-06-11 11:59:28Facebook shut down its Research and Onavo programs after TechCrunch exposed how the company paid teenagers for root access to their phones to gain mar

Yubo is a social network about socializing 2019-06-11 08:33:56Meet Yubo, a French startup that wants to make social networks a bit more… social. Yubo is an app designed for teenagers, and it’s all ab

Shazam for Android now recognizes music played through 2019-06-11 02:51:26Shazam, the Apple-owned app that helps users identify songs playing around them, can now recognize songs you’re listening to through your headph

Changes to Facebook Graph Search leaves online investigators 2019-06-11 00:56:54When Facebook Graph Search launched six years ago, it was meant to help users discover content across public posts on the platform. Since then, the fe

Mashable

Lions are not impressed with Japan zoo's mock 2019-06-22 18:12:42To prepare for the worst, the Tobe Zoo in Japan put a staff member in a lion suit. In the event of an earthquake or some other incident that leads to

Future air travel looks high-tech, autonomous, and electric 2019-06-22 17:00:10While everyone on the ground is stressing about self-driving cars, the future of flight is also moving more toward autonomous planes, as seen at the 2

Mermaid Parade 2019 revelry celebrated Pride, panned Trump, 2019-06-22 16:53:42It's June 22, the first Saturday after the official start of the summer season. And just like they do every year, revelers gathered in New York's Co

This is how much American drivers use their 2019-06-22 15:44:26We just can't stay away from our phones, even in the car.  The drive safety app Drivemode looked at driving data from 2.7 million U.S. drivers u

The world's ugliest dog for 2019 is a 2019-06-22 15:26:44Can you believe it's been an entire year since the bulky English bulldog Zsa Zsa was crowned as the World's Ugliest Dog for 2018? Well, here we are.

Netflix might get picture-in-picture on desktop 2019-06-22 14:48:26Attention power users: Netflix is testing a new feature that'll allow you to watch videos without disrupting your work. According to Engadget, the st

Volkswagen's electric race car set another speed record. 2019-06-22 13:55:18Volkwagen's electric race car took on one of the toughest courses in the world — and set a record.  The VW ID.R with two electric motors t

Walmart's using AI cameras to catch thieves 2019-06-22 12:21:42Think nobody's going to notice if you don't scan that gallon of milk at the self-checkout register? Think again. According to Business Insider, Walm

Toys 'R' Us stores are coming back in 2019-06-22 10:49:13Toys 'R' Us will rise again! After breaking everyone's hearts with its store closures in 2018, Toys 'R' Us will reportedly re-open for business (

An 'It's Always Sunny' dream came true for 2019-06-22 10:43:47Mac finally got his game of catch. It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia fans should remember that Mac (creator Rob McElhenney) dreams of playing catch w

Adam Rippon on Trump, Taylor Swift, and coming 2019-06-22 09:00:00Every day of Pride Month, Mashable will be sharing illuminating conversations with members of the LGBTQ community who are making history right now. Ad

The 10 biggest lies we tell each other 2019-06-22 09:00:00Before deepfakes and alternative facts, the online world was already telling us fibs. In our series Lies the Internet Told Me, we call 'em all out. L

The Next Web

This 3-in-1 wireless charging pad is only $45 2019-06-22 18:00:00The AirZeus 3-in-1 Fast Wireless Charging Pad is not only one of the pace-setters on this new wireless vanguard, it’s ready to be a one-gadget p

Microsoft Azure experts are averaging $130K a year; 2019-06-22 17:30:00Knowing how to use Azure, then construct, grow and secure a truly scalable cloud network is the heart of this training bundle. After getting familiar

Hackers are turning our AI security systems against 2019-06-22 10:00:57With the use of AI growing in almost all areas of business and industry, we have a new problem to worry about – the “hijacking” of a

CHEAP: $60 for this 2TB Western Digital portable 2019-06-22 08:00:45Welcome to CHEAP, our series about things that are good, but most of all, cheap. CHEAP! I love a good hard drive. It’s such a wonderful feeling

New syllabuzz: scientists taught bees to understand numbers 2019-06-22 05:39:58Most children learn that written numbers represent quantities in pre-school or junior primary school. Now our new study shows that honeybees too can l

Malaria won’t be solved by feeding mosquitos sugar, 2019-06-22 03:36:12The teasing temptation of a sugary treat can often get the better of us. But don’t worry, we’re not the only ones. The saccharine substanc

KEF R3 Review: Exemplary speakers that do almost 2019-06-21 19:23:45In the world of enthusiast speakers, few names stand out as much as KEF. The British company has been an influence on high-end audio since the 60s, an

France to create a joint G7 cryptocurrency task 2019-06-21 11:28:50France is putting together a Group of Seven Nations (G7) task force to explore how central banks can make sure cryptocurrencies adhere to money-launde

Bitcoin wallets aren’t addresses — a secret guide 2019-06-21 08:38:46Welcome to Hard Fork Basics, a collection of tips, tricks, guides, and advice to keep you up to date in the cryptocurrency and blockchain world. If yo

Mozilla fixes second Firefox zero-day bug used in 2019-06-21 08:08:06Mozilla has patched its Firefox browser for a second time in response to a spearphishing campaign targeting employees of cryptocurrency exchange

This is how rich you’d be if you 2019-06-18 11:48:05People don’t usually regret their first bit of exciting hardware. On the contrary, the majority of folks have strong nostalgic feelings about th

Crypto Twitter responds to the reality of Facebook’s 2019-06-18 11:25:41Following months of speculation, Facebook finally confirmed the release of Libra next year. The tech giant also unveiled details about Calibra, its co

Entrepreneur

Is Your Company Flexible Enough to Survive Modern 2019-06-22 13:30:00This tech entrepreneur discusses the power of innovation.

New Report Forecasts $40B Global Cannabis Market by 2019-06-22 10:00:00The US is expected to remain by far the largest market on the planet.

Acquire Traffic and Drive Revenue With This $11 2019-06-22 09:30:00The Complete Guide to Digital Marketing will make you an online marketing machine.

Is Slack Really Worth $20 Billion? 2019-06-21 16:30:00The office collaboration company's stock fell on its second trading day.

Why Excuses Are Sometimes Misdiagnosed as a Lack 2019-06-21 16:30:00How do you know if it's your psychology or biology that is holding you back?

Recreational Weed States of America 2019-06-21 16:00:00These states with legal recreational weed made millions from cannabis taxes in 2018.

Facebook Launches a New Cryptocurrency Called Libra 2019-06-21 13:30:00Plus, Lululemon launches a line of personal-care products, and a mental health chatbot app raises $3 million.

How a Breakdown at the Airport Led to 2019-06-21 13:00:00She restructured her life to prioritize what matters most. Now she helps others do the same.

Acquisition vs. Ideation: Is Acquisition Entrepreneurship Your Best 2019-06-21 12:30:00Acquisition entrepreneurship isn't right for every startup idea. But there are a few things you can do to position yourself for success.

5 Ways to Make the Modern Tech Workplace 2019-06-21 12:00:00While it's great to see so many companies supporting diversity and inclusion, we haven't done enough to increase the pipeline for potential women le

How the Top Five 2020 Democratic Candidates' Tax 2019-06-21 11:30:00It's important to educate ourselves about the proposals of Biden, Sanders, Warren, Harris and Buttigieg -- vs. those of the GOP.

Cash Advance Apps Can Be a Short-Term Bridge 2019-06-21 11:00:00If you find yourself short on cash, these services could be a good short-term solution.


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.