• Follow us

Social Media

Facebook’s content oversight board plan is raising more questions than it answers – TechCrunch

Facebook has produced a report summarizing feedback it’s taken in on its idea of establishing a content oversight board to help arbitrate on moderation decisions.

Aka the ‘supreme court of Facebook’ concept first discussed by founder Mark Zuckerberg last year, when he told Vox:

[O]ver the long term, what I’d really like to get to is an independent appeal. So maybe folks at Facebook make the first decision based on the community standards that are outlined, and then people can get a second opinion. You can imagine some sort of structure, almost like a Supreme Court, that is made up of independent folks who don’t work for Facebook, who ultimately make the final judgment call on what should be acceptable speech in a community that reflects the social norms and values of people all around the world.

Facebook has since suggested the oversight board will be up and running later this year. And has just wheeled out its global head of policy and spin for a European PR push to convince regional governments to give it room for self-regulation 2.0, rather than slapping it with broadcast-style regulations.

The latest report, which follows a draft charter unveiled in January, rounds up input fed to Facebook via six “in-depth” workshops and 22 roundtables convened by Facebook and held in locations of its choosing around the world.

In all, Facebook says the events were attended by 650+ people from 88 different countries — though it further qualifies that by saying it had “personal discussions” with more than 250 people and received more than 1,200 public consultation submissions.

“In each of these engagements, the questions outlined in the draft charter led to thoughtful discussions with global perspectives, pushing us to consider multiple angles for how this board could function and be designed,” Facebook writes.

It goes without saying that this input represents a minuscule fraction of the actual ‘population’ of Facebook’s eponymous platform, which now exceeds 2.2BN accounts (an unknown portion of which will be fake/duplicates), while its operations stretch to more than double the number of markets represented by individuals at the events.

The feedback exercise — as indeed the concept of the board itself — is inevitably an exercise in opinion abstraction. Which gives Facebook leeway to shape the output as it prefers. (And, indeed, the full report notes that “some found this public consultation ‘not nearly iterative enough, nor transparent enough, to provide any legitimacy’ to the process of creating the Board”.)

In a blog post providing its spin on the “global feedback and input”, Facebook culls three “general themes” it claims emerged from the various discussions and submissions — namely that: 

People want a board that exercises independent judgment — not judgment influenced by Facebook management, governments or third parties, writing: “The board will need a strong foundation for its decision-making, a set of higher-order principles — informed by free expression and international human rights law — that it can refer to when prioritizing values like safety and voice, privacy and equality”. Though the full report flags up the challenge of ensuring the sought for independence, and it’s not clear Facebook will be able to create a structure that can stand apart from its own company or indeed other lobbyists How the board will select and hear cases, deliberate together, come to a decision and communicate its recommendations both to Facebook and the public are key considerations — though those vital details remain tbc. “In making its decisions, the board may need to consult experts with specific cultural knowledge, technical expertise and an understanding of content moderation,” Facebook suggests, implying the boundaries of the board are unlikely to be firmly fixed People also want a board that’s “as diverse as the many people on Facebook and Instagram” — the problem being that’s clearly impossible, given the planet-spanning size of Facebook platforms. Another desire Facebook highlights is for the board to be able to encourage it to make “better, more transparent decisions”. The need for board decisions (and indeed decisions Facebook takes when setting up the board) to be transparent emerges as a major theme in the report. In terms of the board’s make-up, Facebook says it should comprise experts with different backgrounds, different disciplines, and different viewpoints — “who can all represent the interests of a global community”. Though there’s clearly going to be differing views on how or even whether that’s possible to achieve; and therefore questions over how a 40-odd member body, that will likely rarely sit in plenary, can plausibly act as an prism for Facebook’s user-base

The report is worth reading in full to get a sense of the broad spectrum of governance questions and conundrums Facebook is here wading into.

If, as it very much looks, this is a Facebook-configured exercise in blame spreading for the problems its platform hosts, the surface area for disagreement and dispute will clearly be massive — and from the company’s point of view that already looks like a win. Given how, since 2016, Facebook (and Zuckerberg) have been the conduit for so much public and political anger linked to the spreading and accelerating of harmful online content.

Differing opinions and will also provide cover for Facebook to justify starting “narrow”. Which it has said it will do with the board, aiming to have something up and running by the end of this year. But that just means it’ll be managing expectations of how little actual oversight will flow right from the very start.

The report also shows that Facebook’s claimed ‘listening ear’ for a “global perspective” has some very hard limits.

So while those involved in the consultation are reported to have repeatedly suggested the oversight board should not just be limited to content judgement — but should also be able to make binding decisions related to things like Facebook’s newsfeed algorithm or wider use of AI by the company — Facebook works to shut those suggestions down, underscoring the scope of the oversight will be limited to content.

“The subtitle of the Draft Charter — “An Oversight Board for Content Decisions” — made clear that this body would focus specifically on content. In this regard, Facebook has been relatively clear about the Board’s scope and remit,” it writes. “However, throughout the consultation period, interlocutors often proposed that the Board hear a wide range of controversial and emerging issues: newsfeed ranking, data privacy, issues of local law, artificial intelligence, advertising policies, and so on.”

It goes on to admit that “the question persisted: should the Board be restricted to content decisions only, without much real influence over policy?” — before picking a selection of responses that appear intended to fuzz the issue, allowing it to position itself as seeking a reasoned middle ground.

“In the end, balance will be needed; Facebook will need to resolve tensions between minimalist and maximalist visions of the Board,” it concludes. “Above all, it will have to demonstrate that the Oversight Board — as an enterprise worth doing — adds value, is relevant, and represents a step forward from content governance as it stands today.”

Sample cases the report suggests the board could review — as suggested by participants in Facebook’s consultation — include:

A user shared a list of men working in academia, who were accused of engaging in inappropriate behavior and/or abuse, including unwanted sexual advances; A Page that commonly uses memes and other forms of satire shared posts that used discriminatory remarks to describe a particular demographic group in India; A candidate for office made strong, disparaging remarks to an unknown passerby regarding their gender identity and livestreamed the interaction. Other users reported this due to safety concerns for the latter person; A government official suggested that a local minority group needed to be cautious, comparing that group’s behavior to that of other groups that have faced genocide

So, again, it’s easy to see the kinds of controversies and indeed criticisms that individuals sitting on Facebook’s board will be opening themselves up to — whichever way their decisions fall.

A content review board that will inevitably remain linked to (if not also reimbursed via) the company that establishes it, and will not be granted powers to set wider Facebook policy — but will instead be tasked with facing the impossible of trying to please all of the Facebook users (and critics) all of the time — does certainly risk looking like Facebook’s stooge; a conduit for channeling dirty and political content problems that have the potential to go viral and threaten its continued ability to monetize the stuff that’s uploaded to its platforms.

Facebook’s preferred choice of phrase to describe its users — “global community” — is a tellingly flat one in this regard.

The company conspicuously avoids talk of communities, plural — instead the closest we get here is a claim that its selective consultation exercise is “ensuring a global perspective”, as if a singular essence can somehow be distilled from a non-representative sample of human opinion — when in fact the stuff that flows across its platforms is quite the opposite; multitudes of perspectives from individuals and communities whose shared use of Facebook does not an emergent ‘global community’ make.

This is why Facebook has struggled to impose a single set of ‘community standards’ across a platform that spans so many contexts; a one-size-fits all approach very clearly doesn’t fit.

Yet it’s not at all clear how Facebook creating yet another layer of content review changes anything much for that challenge — unless the oversight body is mostly intended to act as a human shield for the company itself, putting a firewall between it and certain highly controversial content; aka Facebook’s supreme court of taking the blame on its behalf.

Just one of the difficult content moderation issues embedded in the businesses of sociotechnical, planet-spanning social media platform giants like Facebook — hate speech — defies a top-down ‘global’ fix.

As Evelyn Douek wrote last year vis-a-via hate speech on the Lawfare blog, after Zuckerberg had floated the idea of a governance structure for online speech: “Even if it were possible to draw clear jurisdictional lines and create robust rules for what constitutes hate speech in countries across the globe, this is only the beginning of the problem: within each jurisdiction, hate speech is deeply context-dependent… This context dependence presents a practically insuperable problem for a platform with over 2 billion users uploading vast amounts of material every second.”

A cynic would say Facebook knows it can’t fix planet-scale content moderation and still turn a profit. So it needs a way to distract attention and shift blame.

If it can get enough outsiders to buy into its oversight board — allowing it to pass off the oxymoron of “global governance”, via whatever self-styled structure it allows to emerge from these self-regulatory seeds — the company’s hope must be that the device also works as a bolster against political pressure.

Both over particular problem/controversial content, and also as a vehicle to shrink the space for governments to regulate Facebook.

In a video discussion also embedded in Facebook’s blog post — in which Zuckerberg couches the oversight board project as “a big experiment that we hope can pioneer a new model for the governance of speech on the Internet” — the Facebook founder also makes reference to calls he’s made for more regulation of the Internet. As he does so he immediately qualifies the statement by blending state regulation with industry self-regulation — saying the kind of regulation he’s asking for is “in some cases by democratic process, in other cases through independent industry process”.

So Zuckerberg is making a clear pitch to position Facebook as above the rule of nation state law — and setting up a “global governance” layer is the self-serving vehicle of choice for the company to try and overtake democracy.

Even if Facebook’s oversight board’s structure is so cunningly fashioned as to present to a rationally minded individual as, in some senses, ‘independent’ from Facebook, its entire being and function will remain dependent on Facebook’s continued existence.

Whereas if individual markets impose their own statutory regulations on Internet platforms, based on democratic and societal principles, Facebook will have no control over the rules they impose, direct or otherwise — with uncontrolled compliance costs falling on its business.

It’s easy to see which model sits most easily with Zuckerberg the businessman — a man who has also demonstrated he will not be held personally accountable for what happens on his platform.

Not when he’s asked by one (non-US) parliament, nor even by representatives from nine parliaments — all keen to discuss the societal fallouts of political disinformation and hate speech spread and accelerated on Facebook.

Turns out that’s not the kind of ‘global perspective’ Facebook wants to sell you.

Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

TechCrunch » Social

Atlan raises $2.5M to stop enterprises from being 2019-07-01 19:35:14Even as much of the world is digitizing its governance, in small towns and villages of India, data about its citizens is still being largely logged on

Secret Border Patrol Facebook group is brimming with 2019-07-01 15:08:08At a time when immigration and border issues are foremost on Americans' minds, the integrity of the men and women who enforce those policies is simil

Daily Crunch: Facebook is ‘too narrow’ on removing 2019-07-01 13:40:25The Daily Crunch is TechCrunch’s roundup of our biggest and most important stories. If you’d like to get this delivered to your inbox ever

Girlboss pivots to provide a LinkedIn for professional 2019-07-01 13:28:08Girlboss is the multi-media brand for women founded by serial entrepreneur Sophia Amoruso, whose last company, Nasty Gal, presaged the direct to consu

Spark Networks SE closes its $258M acquisition of 2019-07-01 13:12:56Berlin-based Spark Networks, the owner of niche dating app brands like Christian Mingle, Jdate, LDSsingles, Silver Singles, JSwipe and others, today a

Facebook civil rights audit says white supremacy policy 2019-06-30 18:00:26Facebook’s second progress report pertaining to the civil rights audit conducted by former ACLU Washington Director Laura Murphy is here. Over t

Adopting a ratings system for social media like 2019-06-30 09:30:19Internet platforms like Google, Facebook and Twitter are under incredible pressure to reduce the proliferation of illegal and abhorrent content on the

Facebook SDK bug crashed apps like Timehop 2019-06-28 16:33:24A malfunction in Facebook’s Software Development Kit that lets apps add Login With Facebook, sharing, and other features caused apps that integr

Apple tries out the ‘choose-your-own adventure’ Twitter thread 2019-06-28 14:52:02It looks like choose-your-own-adventure Twitter games won’t be a one-hit wonder, now that Apple’s social team has adopted the format. A ne

How startups can make influencer marketing work on 2019-06-28 14:40:31Influencer Marketing has ballooned into a $25 billion industry, yet many marketing managers are left confused by this, because for them, it’s re

Italy stings Facebook with $1.1M fine for Cambridge 2019-06-28 09:50:08Italy’s data protection watchdog has issued Facebook with a €1 million (~$1.1M) fine for violations of local privacy law attached to the Ca

Facebook’s content oversight board plan is raising more 2019-06-28 08:08:27Facebook has produced a report summarizing feedback it’s taken in on its idea of establishing a content oversight board to help arbitrate on mod

Mashable

Fourth of July 2019 sales: Best deals on 2019-07-03 14:32:28The Fourth of July is already up on us. Whether your national anthem is the star spangled one or the one by Lana Del Rey, there's one thing we'

This Sony soundbar has Bluetooth built in — 2019-07-03 13:47:52TL;DR: This sleek Sony soundbar with built-in Bluetooth usually retails for $198, but Amazon's got it on sale right now for just $148 — a 25% s

Tesla delivers 95,200 cars in Q2, breaking record 2019-07-03 12:40:48The Elon Musk-run company recently hit a rough first quarter. However, this news is a step in the right direction for Tesla.Read more here. Read more.

Volkswagen reveals electric concept car modeled after 1962 2019-07-03 12:39:48The company unveiled the concept car at IECC. The vehicle is all-electric and was converted from a 57-year-old Type 2 van.Read more here. Read more...

Giant pool float sale: Save up to $50 2019-07-03 12:29:10Whether you’re hosting a pool party, just catching some sun, or trying to get an Instagram-worthy picture, pool floats are the perfect summer ac

Megan Rapinoe gives champion-level response to the tea 2019-07-03 12:23:51Megan Rapinoe may not have seen the field during the U.S. women's World Cup semifinal win over England on Tuesday, but she still had a big impact off

Hailie Sahar on how 'Good Trouble' and 'Pose' 2019-07-03 12:13:54The newest episode of Freeform’s Good Trouble centers on recurring character Jazmin Martinez’s 30th birthday double quinceañera. It

This Kuvings cold press juicer can process whole 2019-07-03 12:09:58TL;DR: This whole fruit slow juicer is priced at $399.95 on Kuvings' website, but Amazon has it on sale for only $359. Just as you swapped your puffy

Turn your arm into a touch screen with 2019-07-03 12:06:52'Lumiwatch' is an on-arm projection smartwatch. The fully-functional, self-contained device offers 40 square centimeters of interactive surface area

Ultimate Ears Blast wireless speaker is waterproof and 2019-07-03 11:34:31TL;DR: The waterproof Ultimate Ears Blast wireless speaker is on sale for $69.99 saving you $110. This summer is bringing the heat with music, y'all.

Ninja Chef high-speed blender is $50 off at 2019-07-03 11:30:41TL;DR: The powerful Ninja Chef high-speed blender is on sale for $109 at Walmart, saving you $50. We love a good combination appliance that does the w

The George Foreman indoor/outdoor grill is on sale 2019-07-03 11:26:36TL;DR: You can score this surprisingly spacious George Foreman indoor/outdoor electric grill at Walmart for just $59.99, a savings of $39 off the regu

The Next Web

The Flair Signature Pro makes brewing delicious espresso 2019-07-03 13:59:33I never expected to become an amateur barista. A little over a year ago, I decided to stop spending so much money buying iced mochas at coffee shops a

Ethereum still loved by dapp developers, but trails 2019-07-03 11:23:26Ethereum might feature more decentralized apps (dapps) than any other blockchain, but its rivals are enjoying significantly higher usage. In fact

How to keep YouTube videos playing in the 2019-07-03 11:15:33Welcome to TNW Basics, a collection of tips, guides, and advice on how to easily get the most out of your gadgets, apps, and other stuff. I love

The Cowboy e-bike is so good I want 2019-07-03 11:14:16I’m going to get straight to the point: I’ve tested out a few electric bikes in my time, and while I love the VanMoof Electrified 2 series

‘The world’s greatest email app’ is a privacy 2019-07-03 10:42:30Superhuman bills itself as the world’s greatest email client. It should, given how much it costs; users of the app pay $30 a month for a subscri

Here’s how gamification can help your business understand 2019-07-03 09:54:56Today’s operations require more comprehensive stores of information, most of which deals expressly in the human behavior of consumers or interna

You can kickstart a lucrative DevOps career with 2019-07-03 09:00:00Applying this logic to your professional development, continuing to learn new skills is key to surviving and staying relevant. DevOps is a new methodo

CHEAP: [inner peace] > this can be yours 2019-07-03 08:49:44Welcome to CHEAP, our series about things that are good, but most of all, cheap. CHEAP! Honestly, noise-canceling headphones are a must today. Noisy p

UK regulator wants crypto-derivatives ban to protect ‘ill-suited’ 2019-07-03 08:43:21The UK‘s Financial Conduct Authority has proposed a ban on cryptocurrency-related investment products to protect retail investors. In an announc

Android creator Andy Rubin accused of running a 2019-07-03 07:53:36Android founder, Andy Rubin, may have left Google long back in 2014, but his departure is beginning to attract more unsavory attention as more informa

Is Microsoft teasing a Netflix tie-in? Stranger Things 2019-07-02 16:45:15Microsoft yesterday took to Twitter and Instagram to tease social media denizens with a cryptic Windows 1.0 video. After you check your calendar to ma

Researchers invent multiplayer Tetris game controlled by brainwaves 2019-07-02 15:23:47A team of scientists from the University of Washington and Carnegie Mellon University have developed a method by which three people can play a Tetris-

Entrepreneur

4 Tech Trends That Are Positively Changing Workplaces 2019-07-03 14:00:00From reporting bad behavior to allowing more flexibility, these advancements help everyone.

What Are the Right Questions to Ask When 2019-07-03 13:30:00Focus on the important stuff at the start of your entrepreneurial journey.

Listen: New Opportunities in the Cannabis Business 2019-07-03 13:22:00G. Ryan Ansin is a top tier investor and founder of Revolution Farms. Here's where he sees the business going.

How 7 High-Performing CEOs Maintain Massive Momentum in 2019-07-03 13:00:00Do the little things every day.

6 Steps to Boost the Value of Your 2019-07-03 12:00:00If you run an online shop, don't you dare sell it before checking this list.

5 Business and Life Lessons on Grit and 2019-07-03 11:00:00Grit and determination were the characteristics this famous socialite, author and actress offered the world.

Tesla Stock Jumps 7 Percent After Setting Quarterly 2019-07-03 11:00:00The Entrepreneur Index™ starts the second half of the year on a high note.

How a Surprise Round of Funding Suddenly Saved 2019-07-03 10:30:00This tech company has now earned millions in investments.

How We Can Beat Venture Capital's Diversity Problem 2019-07-03 10:00:00Minorities and females are yet to be fully integrated into the venture-backed technology world. So, what can we do?

China Is Installing Spyware on Tourists' Phones 2019-07-03 09:51:56The app is forcefully installed at border crossings and collects all your personal information.

Auto Industry Leader Lee Iacocca, Credited With Saving 2019-07-03 09:50:04He is best known for helping launch the Ford Mustang in the 1960s and for reviving Chrysler under his leadership and saving it from bankruptcy in the

Entrepreneur Insider Video of the Week: Use Instagram 2019-07-03 09:00:00Watch this free Entrepreneur Insider session with digital marketing expert Jon Horowitz, who will teach you how to attract your ideal audience, boost


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.