• Follow us

Social Media

YouTube tightens restrictions on channel of UK far right activist — but no ban – TechCrunch

YouTube has placed new restrictions on the channel of a UK far right activist which are intended to make hate speech less easy to discover on its platform.

Restrictions on Stephen Yaxley-Lennon’s YouTube channel include removing certain of his videos from recommendations. YouTube is also taking away his ability to livestream to his now close to 390,000 YouTube channel subscribers.

Yaxley-Lennon, who goes by the name ‘Tommy Robinson’ on social media, was banned from Twitter a year ago.

Buzzfeed first reported the new restrictions. A YouTube spokesperson confirmed the shift in policy, telling us: “After consulting with third party experts, we are applying a tougher treatment to Tommy Robinson’s channel in keeping with our policies on borderline content. The content will be placed behind an interstitial, removed from recommendations, and stripped of key features including livestreaming, comments, suggested videos, and likes.”

Test searches for ‘Tommy Robinson’ on YouTube now return a series of news reports — instead of Yaxley-Lennon’s own channel, as was the case just last month.

YouTube had already demonetized Yaxley-Lennon’s channel back in January for violating its ad policies.

But as we reported last month Google has been under increasing political pressure in the UK to tighten its policies over the far right activist.

The policy shift applies to videos uploaded by Yaxley-Lennon that aren’t illegal or otherwise in breach of YouTube’s community standards (as the company applies them) but which have nonetheless been flagged by users as potential violations of the platform’s policies on hate speech and violent extremism.

In such instances YouTube says it will review the videos and those not in violation of its policies but which nonetheless contain controversial religious or extremist content will be placed behind an interstitial, removed from recommendations, and stripped of key features including comments, suggested videos, and likes.

Such videos will also not be eligible for monetization.

The company says its goal with the stricter approach to Yaxley-Lennon’s content is to strike a balance between upholding free expression and a point of public and historic record, while also keeping hateful content from being spread or recommended to others.

YouTube said it carefully considered Yaxley-Lennon’s case — consulting with external experts and UK academics — before deciding it needed to take tougher treatment.

Affected videos will still remain on YouTube — albeit behind an interstitial. They also won’t be recommended, and will be stripped of the usual social features including comments, suggested videos, and likes.

Of course it remains to be seen how tightly YouTube will apply the new more restrictive policy in this case. And whether Yaxley-Lennon himself will adapt his video strategy to workaround tighter rules on that channel.

The far right is very well versed in using coded language and dog whistle tactics to communicate with its followers and spread racist messages under the mainstream radar.

Yaxley-Lennon has had a presence on multiple social media channels, adapting the content to the different platforms. Though YouTube is the last mainstream channel still available to him after Facebook kicked him off its platform in February. Albeit, he was quickly able to workaround Facebook’s ban simply by using a friend’s Facebook account to livestream himself harassing a journalist at his home late at night.

Police were called out twice in that instance. And in a vlog uploaded to YouTube after the incident Yaxley-Lennon threatened other journalists to “expect a knock at the door”.

Shortly afterwards the deputy leader of the official opposition raised his use of YouTube to livestream harassment in parliament, telling MPs then that: “Every major social media platform other than YouTube has taken down Stephen Yaxley-Lennon’s profile because of his hateful conduct.”

The secretary of state for digital, Jeremy Wright, responded by urging YouTube to “reconsider their judgement” — saying: “We all believe in freedom of speech. But we all believe too that that freedom of speech has limits. And we believe that those who seek to intimidate others, to potentially of course break the law… that is unacceptable. That is beyond the reach of the type of freedom of speech that we believe should be protected.”

YouTube claims it removes videos that violate its hate speech and violent content policies. But in previous instances involving Yaxley-Lennon it has told us that specific videos of his — including the livestreamed harassment that was raised in parliament — do not constitute a breach of its standards.

It’s now essentially admitting that those standards are too weak in instances of weaponized hate.

Yaxley-Lennon, a former member of the neo-nazi British National Party and one of the founders of the far right, Islamophobic English Defence League, has used social media to amplify his message of hate while also soliciting donations to fund individual far right ‘activism’ — under the ‘Tommy Robinson’ moniker.

The new YouTube restrictions could reduce his ability to leverage the breadth of Google’s social platform to reach a wider and more mainstream audience than he otherwise would.

Albeit, it remains trivially easy for anyone who already knows the ‘Tommy Robinson’ ‘brand’ to workaround the YouTube restrictions by using another mainstream Google-owned technology. A simple Google search for “Tommy Robinson YouTube channel” returns direct links to his channel and content at the top of search results. 

Yaxley-Lennon’s followers will also continue to be able to find and share his YouTube content by sharing direct links to it — including on mainstream social platforms.

Though the livestream ban is a significant restriction — if it’s universally applied to the channel — which will make it harder for Yaxley-Lennon to communicate instantly at a distance with followers in his emotive vlogging medium of choice.

He has used the livestreaming medium skilfully to amplify and whip up hate while presenting himself to his followers as a family man afraid for his wife and children. (For the record: Yaxley-Lennon’s criminal record includes convictions for violence, public order offences, drug possession, financial and immigration frauds, among other convictions.)

If Google is hoping to please everyone by applying a ‘third route’ of tighter restrictions for a hate speech weaponizer yet no total ban it will likely just end up pleasing no one and taking flak from both sides.

The company does point out it removes channels of proscribed groups and any individuals formally linked to such groups. And in this case the related far right groups have not been proscribed by the UK government. So the UK government could certainly do much more to check the rise of domestic far right hate.

But YouTube could also step up and take a leadership position by setting robust policies against individuals who seek to weaponize hate.

Instead it continues to fiddle around the edges — trying to fudge the issue by claiming it’s about ‘balancing’ speech and community safety.

In truth hate speech suppresses the speech of those it targets with harassment. So if social networks really want to maximize free speech across their communities they have to be prepared to weed out bad actors who would shrink the speech of minorities by weaponizing hate against them.

Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

TechCrunch » Social

YouTube tightens restrictions on channel of UK far 2019-04-02 06:38:47YouTube has placed new restrictions on the channel of a UK far right activist which are intended to make hate speech less easy to discover on its plat

Facebook asks for public input about its plans 2019-04-01 12:52:07In November, Facebook announced its plans to create an external content oversight board that would serve as something of a “supreme court”

German LinkedIn rival Xing is rebranding as ‘New 2019-04-01 11:17:49Xing, the business networking platform that has been described as Germany’s answer to LinkedIn, has made an acquisition to beef up its recruitme

New Facebook tool answers the question ‘Why am 2019-03-31 23:34:32Facebook announced today that it is adding to News Feeds a feature called “Why am I seeing this post?” Similar to “Why am I seeing t

Mark Zuckerberg actually calls for regulation of content, 2019-03-30 16:41:33It’s been a busy day for Facebook exec op-eds. Earlier this morning, Sheryl Sandberg broke the site’s silence around the Christchurch mass

Snap CEO’s sister Caroline Spiegel starts a no-visuals 2019-03-29 10:15:24If you took the photos and videos out of pornography, could it appeal to a new audience? Caroline Spiegel’s first startup Quinn aims to bring so

Facebook’s handling of Alex Jones is a microcosm 2019-03-28 19:32:29A revealing cluster of emails reviewed by Business Insider and Channel 4 News offers a glimpse at the fairly chaotic process of how Facebook decides w

Facebook launches searchable transparency library of all active 2019-03-28 19:00:05Now you can search Facebook for how much Trump has spent on ads in the past year, which Pages’ ads reference immigration or what a Page’s

Facebook needs a white hat Cambridge Analytica 2019-03-28 15:30:53If the tech giants don’t want regulators to step in and police, they need to do much more to predict, and stop the abuse, before it even happens

Twitter introduces a battery-saving ‘Lights Out’ dark-mode option 2019-03-28 13:58:59As promised back in January by Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey, the company today is rolling out an even darker version of the app’s existing dark mode.

HUD hits Facebook with housing discrimination charges over 2019-03-28 09:40:03The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development this morning hit Facebook with charges of housing discrimination. The filing states that the onli

Facebook is finally banning white supremacy that goes 2019-03-27 13:23:24Facebook is abandoning a longstanding policy of allowing white supremacy to flourish on its platform under the guise of terms like white nationalism a

Mashable

Braun electric shavers, Garmin smartwatches, Samsung TVs, and 2019-04-04 07:09:37There's a little bit of everything in this deals round up, with electric toothbushes, electric shavers, TVs, sat navs, Amazon devices, and more in th

Zachary Levi turns James Corden into a real-life 2019-04-04 06:30:05 If you could have just one superpower, you'd probably want it be something kind of useful, right? Well, apparently you don't really get a choice.

'Game of Thrones' sisters Maisie Williams and Sophie 2019-04-04 06:30:00Game of Thrones will eventually be gone from our lives. The thought is excruciatingly painful, but it's just something we're going to have to come t

'The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina' Season 2 goes 2019-04-04 06:00:00When a show promises witch stuff, it better deliver on witch stuff. The first season of Riverdale spinoff The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina almost ca

Sheryl Crow’s Tesla screen goes dark, Elon Musk 2019-04-04 05:53:47What do you do when your Tesla's screen goes black? Well, you take it to Twitter and have Elon Musk solve the problem for you, of course.  It pr

Tesla's Model S and X deliveries plummet in 2019-04-04 05:12:25Tesla's vehicle production & deliveries report for the first quarter of 2019 is out, and it's not great.  Not so much because of the 31 per

Oberyn tried to get revenge on The Mountain 2019-04-04 05:11:352019 marks the final season of Game of Thrones — so it was only fitting that the last ever red carpet event was suitably epic. Well, judging by

These cheap kitchen sponges double as oven mitts, 2019-04-04 05:00:00What lives in your sink and is way, way past its prime? A smelly, dirty, moldy sponge that's full of bacteria.  With the exception of Spongebob

Stephen Colbert uses strong Harry Potter comparison to 2019-04-04 02:26:14 Attorney General William Barr's four-page summary of Robert Mueller's almost two-year investigation is a little too short for many, as the House

Lincoln Aviator SUV returns with 28-speaker sound system 2019-04-04 00:01:00The Lincoln Aviator SUV is back and making some noise after the American car maker pulled the three-row SUV back in 2005.  The noisy return might

'Toy Story 4' debuts first 17 minutes at 2019-04-03 23:53:05If you've ever wished that sweet family films would have more existential despair in them, Toy Story 4 may be for you. And not just because of Forky.

'Dark Phoenix' will probably be the end of 2019-04-03 23:09:21The X-Men are part of the Disney family now, and never has that felt clearer than at the studio's CinemaCon presentation Wednesday. Disney touted bot

The Next Web

Beats’ new Powerbeats Pro want to be Airpods 2019-04-04 07:22:54There’s big movements going on at Apple‘s audio wing. First, the Airpods were updated. And now? The Apple-owned Beats by Dre is getting it

Indian entrepreneur implicated in $300 million Bitcoin Ponzi 2019-04-04 06:46:04Amit Bhardwaj, a man accused of running a $300-million Bitcoin Ponzi scheme, has reportedly been granted bail on medical grounds, citing a deteri

Bitcoin’s price surge pushes cryptocurrency-related stocks into the 2019-04-04 05:20:42Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies weren’t the only investments to benefit from the leading coin‘s recent price jump. The cryptocurrency m

Canada confiscates $1.4M in Bitcoin from dark web 2019-04-04 04:48:22A Canadian judge has ordered the forfeiture of approximately $1.4 million in Bitcoin found on a drug dealer’s computer as part of a cr

Watch Adobe’s new After Effects feature remove distracting 2019-04-04 03:54:02Adobe’s just updated its popular After Effects video editing software with an incredibly handy feature: the ability to select and remove unwante

Why the world is unhappy with India’s anti-satellite 2019-04-04 02:45:57On March 27, Indian Prime Minister, Narendra Modi, announced that the country had successfully launched an anti-satellite missile in Low Earth Or

‘Consent condom’ requires four hands to open package 2019-04-03 22:30:5494 percent of women who are raped experience symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder. One in three will contemplate suicide. And while a condom isn

Salty Fallout 76 player sends sassiest message ever 2019-04-03 18:08:59If you’ve ever wished to communicate with a game developer, either to praise them or to complain about something, but chickened out because you

Facebook data leak (yeah, another one) allegedly exposes 2019-04-03 17:23:13Flip that board that says “It’s been _ days since we found a massive pile of unsecured Facebook data” right back to zero, and get re

Stepping into the immersive classroom 2019-04-03 16:35:52In a beautifully kitted out room in central Paris, Colin Fillaudeau is teaching a group of youngsters how to build in Mixed Reality. Even though my Fr

Android Q Beta 2 is now available, including 2019-04-03 14:13:45Well, that was fast. Less than a month after it released the first beta of Android Q, Google has now released Beta 2. While it’s mostly aimed at

TNW2019 Daily: On the right track 2019-04-03 11:17:49We have only 36 days left until TNW2019, our tech conference in Amsterdam! Here are some fun facts about the number 36: It appears in the title of Wu-

Entrepreneur

Famed Journalist and Cancer Survivor Tom Brokaw Reveals 2019-04-03 14:30:00Brokaw's legendary probity makes his public admission a landmark in erasing marijuana's fading stigma.

These 5 Questions Can Help You Set Better 2019-04-03 13:30:00Financial expert Jeff Rose breaks down how you can identify goals that you'll actually have the motivation to achieve.

This Week in Weed: Seth Rogen Starts a 2019-04-03 13:23:18A big celebrity gets into the weed game, the FDA sets a date, and someone else got my dream job!

Upwork to Charge Freelancers to Bid on Jobs, 2019-04-03 12:27:00Freelancers will soon have to pay as much as $0.90 for each job they apply for on Upwork, which could impact users who are new to the platform or stru

What Are the Duties of a CEO? 2019-04-03 12:00:00Every company has one, but their roles can vary greatly. So, what exactly should you, as CEO, be doing?

Minted Grew From a Stationery Brand to a 2019-04-03 11:31:00By listening to her community and reacting quickly, Mariam Naficy built a business bigger than her wildest visions.

How Apple's March 25 Announcement Looks a Lot 2019-04-03 11:00:00The battle among the titans of tech for the 'digital' throne is just like the battle for the 'iron' one.

Exercise Officially Makes You Happier Than Money, According 2019-04-03 10:56:20The team also noticed that certain sports that involve socializing can have more of a positive effect on your mental health than others.

How This Direct-Mail Piece Packs a Small but 2019-04-03 10:45:00Postcards can't hold much copy but when done right, you'll see your business grow.

New TSA Scanning Tech Will Let You Keep 2019-04-03 10:32:50The Transportation Security Administration will start installing the new X-ray scanning systems in U.S. airports this summer.

How Should a Leader Deal With Unexpected Rejection? 2019-04-03 10:30:00This CEO shares his experience.

Daily Rituals That Lead to High Performance in 2019-04-03 10:19:00Dr. Mike Gervais discusses mental and physical tactics for becoming the best possible version of yourself.


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.