• Follow us


How anti-abortion activists went from 'chipping away' at Roe vs. Wade to swinging a sledgehammer | CBC News

The anti-abortion movement is hitting an aggressive new stride in the United States. Whether it breaks into a sprint toward the Supreme Court is worrying reproductive rights activists amid a renewed push to reverse the long-standing precedent that legalized abortions.

As part of a frenzy of recent legislative activity, Alabama and Missouri last week sought to criminalize nearly all abortions in a bid to dismantle Roe vs. Wade, the landmark 1973 decision that legalized a woman's right to have the procedure.

Ultra-conservatives hope to force the U.S. Supreme Court to revisit legal abortion through one of those cases. With the confirmations of justices Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh, a 5-4 conservative majority now tilts the bench.

A handful of bills have also passed in Georgia, Kentucky, Mississippi and Ohio in recent months, in some cases banning abortions as early as after six weeks — before many women even realize they're pregnant.

Abortion rights activist Fiona Good, left, demonstrates for Planned Parenthood outside the U.S. Supreme Court in Washington on Tuesday. She was met by counter-protester Alison Centofante, right, with the anti-abortion group Live Action. A new law in Alabama takes direct aim at Roe vs. Wade, the 1973 ruling that legalized a woman's right to abortion in the U.S. (Lyndsay Duncombe/CBC)

"The fact that these bills are passing in the lead-up to what will likely to be another emotionally charged election year adds to that feeling of imminence — that it's now or never, because who knows what happens in 2020," said Amy Swearer, a senior legal policy analyst with the Heritage Foundation, a conservative think-tank.

She said the country's top court might begin "slowly allowing states to implement more types of restrictions at earlier points during the pregnancy."

But a more dramatic attempt is underway to outright undo the abortion law, according to Mary Ziegler, a law professor at Florida State University and author of Beyond Abortion: Roe v. Wade and the Fight for Privacy.

Amplifying efforts, she said, is confidence from anti-abortion "absolutists" that efforts to take a direct shot at reversing Roe — rather than stripping it away via "death by a thousand cuts" — might actually succeed under the Supreme Court's new composition.

"The absolutists traditionally weren't that influential in the [Republican Party] because they weren't that pragmatic," Ziegler said. "They're now gaining more power, in part, because they can convince state lawmakers in some places that there's a chance the Supreme Court will uphold these kind of restrictive laws."

The election of Donald Trump, she added, may have convinced Republicans to take a more hardline approach, as well as to appeal to an energized base, rather than to the majority of voters in the middle.

A wire hanger used as sign of protest is pictured during a 'Stop the Abortion Ban Bill' day of action in St. Louis, Mo., on Tuesday. (Lawrence Bryant/Reuters)

Asked if Roe vs. Wade was now in peril, Ziegler was unequivocal.

"The short answer is yes," she said. "I would say Roe is safe if you're interested in the next year or two — but not long term."

Although some states have long aimed to restrict abortions by whittling away access, Alabama's law targets Roe vs. Wade directly and is seen by critics as trying to trigger a fight in the country's highest court.

"The difference is entirely strategic," Ziegler said.

The Alabama law recently signed by the governor would be the tip of one spear. That bill seeks to ban abortion at any stage of pregnancy, including in cases of rape or incest. Doctors who perform the procedure could face up to 99 years behind bars. The only exception would be when a woman's health is at serious risk.

Another frontal assault on Roe would be Georgia's "heartbeat" bill, which bans most abortions after just six weeks. 

"That's not that different from an outright ban," said Dick Howard, an expert on the Supreme Court and constitutional law with the University of Virginia. Such laws, he said, are almost certainly intended "to force their way onto the docket of the Supreme Court."

Whichever cases are taken up come at the court's discretion, so even a potential review of Roe vs. Wade by the justices would be seen as an opening for anti-abortion groups.  

A woman dressed in costume inspired by Margaret Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale attends a protest against anti-abortion legislation in Washington on Tuesday. (James Lawler Duggan/Reuters)

That's due in part to the 1973 decision's vulnerability. The law was built on a shaky legal foundation in the first place, Ziegler said.

Roe was premised on the idea of a "right to privacy." Yet nowhere in the U.S. Constitution is abortion explicitly mentioned. That left it up to the justices during the original case to make inferences based on earlier decisions on issues like the right to privacy for contraception and parenting.

The justices concluded right to privacy should extend the right to cover abortion.

"People found that kind of unconvincing because, of course, it's controversial whether the constitution recognizes the abortion right," Ziegler said. "Progressive scholars pretty much immediately went to work identifying what they thought were better arguments for abortion rights."

It would take four votes from justices to agree the case deserves review, explained Glenn Cohen, a bioethicist and lawyer with Harvard Law School.

Missouri has become just the latest U.S. state where abortion rights are colliding with politics and religion. The CBC's Lyndsay Duncombe looks at how that fight is playing out south of the border. 9:09

"It's the kind of case where they're unlikely to take the case unless they have five votes to get rid of Roe v. Wade," he said, as well as enough votes to overturn Casey vs. Planned Parenthood, the 1992 ruling that partially reaffirmed the abortion law.

Cohen said he can't foresee both Gorsuch and Kavanaugh facially overruling Roe. And Chief Justice John Roberts, who is also a conservative, has shown himself to be an "institutionalist" keen to protect the court's reputation, he added.

Harm to the court's standing — either as a non-partisan branch of the government or as a body that respects determined precedent — might give the justices pause about whether to take on the case.

"If the court did uphold the Alabama law, then other states would be free to pass similar laws — and might," Cohen said.

For her part, Georgetown University's constitutional law scholar Susan Low Bloch doubts Roe will be overturned, at least in the short term.

Susan Low Bloch, a constitutional law scholar with Georgetown University, says she believes Roe vs. Wade is secure 'at least for the immediate future.' (Marie Claudet/CBC)

Even if the individual state cases do as they were designed and get taken up by the Supreme Court, Bloch said she remains "absolutely confident they will find it to be unconstitutional and it will not require them to reconsider Roe v. Wade."

The laws currently being passed are so "draconian" and "extreme," she said, that she expects the court will easily find them to be unconstitutional. 

"I don't think Roe v. Wade will get overturned even in the foreseeable future. It will be chipped away at."

The anti-abortion movement has thus far focused on making it harder to get the procedure via restrictions like requiring admitting privileges for doctors, imposing onerous licensing standards, demanding specific widths of corridors and requiring for multiple visits before an abortion is performed — rules that both increase costs and create barriers to access.

As Bloch sees it though, the Alabama law is an entirely different weapon — one that's meant to bring the whole U.S. abortion law crashing down.

"That is not chipping away," she said. "That's a sledgehammer."

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News

FOX News

Iran agrees to hand over detained US resident 2019-06-11 05:02:53Iran has agreed to hand over a U.S. permanent resident imprisoned for years in Tehran to Lebanese officials, an Iranian judiciary official said Tuesda

Japan's former empress has heart problem but fine 2019-06-11 05:02:00Japan's 84-year-old former Empress Michiko has left for a three-day trip to the city of Kyoto, with her doctors saying she has a heart problem but is

Source for water contamination in Norway not yet 2019-06-11 04:37:56Norwegian authorities say they have not yet identified the source of water contamination in southern Norway that sent dozens of people to the hospital

Russian parliament speaker concerned about journalist's case 2019-06-11 04:21:26The speaker of the upper house of the Russian parliament has raised concerns about a drug dealing case against a prominent investigative journalist.

New Zealand court stops man from being extradited 2019-06-11 04:20:24A New Zealand court has stopped a man accused of murder from being extradited to China, at least for now, due to concerns he could be tortured.

Russian newspapers put up rare, united front following 2019-06-11 03:59:58Three Russian newspapers used their front pages in a unique cry for press freedom Monday after a journalist known for his extensive career investigati

Thai junta chief proclaimed second-time prime minister 2019-06-11 03:17:55Thailand's junta leader has been officially proclaimed prime minister after the king endorsed Parliament's vote to allow him to keep the position.

South Korea agencies can't confirm Kim brother as 2019-06-11 03:12:34South Korean agencies say they cannot confirm a report that the half brother of North Korean leader Kim Jong Un was a U.S. intelligence source and tra

When disaster hits, Indonesia's Islamists are first to 2019-06-11 02:39:51The two flags hanging outside Anwar Ragaua's house have gotten him police warnings but the wiry 50-year-old vows he's not taking them down.

Afghan forces rescue 34 people form Taliban-run prison 2019-06-11 02:30:19The Interior Ministry says Afghan special forces have rescued 34 people from a Taliban-run prison in northern Baghlan province.

Greece: Rescue operation underway after migrant boat capsize 2019-06-11 02:28:39Greece's coast guard says a search and rescue operation is underway off the coast of the eastern Aegean island of Lesbos after a boat carrying dozens

Indian toddler trapped in well dies amid 110-hour 2019-06-11 02:27:16A hospital official in India says a 2-year-old boy who fell deep into an unused village well has been confirmed dead after rescuers worked nearly 110


Iran says detained US resident to be released 2019-06-11 03:44:23TEHRAN, Iran (AP) - Iran has agreed to hand over a U.S. permanent resident imprisoned for years in Tehran to Lebanese officials, an Iranian judiciary

As investors watch trade wars, other problems percolate 2019-06-11 03:00:59NEW YORK (AP) - Once this trade-war cloud gets lifted, investors should have little to worry about, right? Monday's market action makes it seem that

Former S. Korean first lady, feminist Lee Hee-ho 2019-06-10 23:48:23SEOUL, South Korea (AP) - Lee Hee-ho, a South Korean feminist activist who fought for democracy against dictatorships alongside her husband and future

Iran revokes New York Times correspondent's accreditation 2019-06-10 23:42:46DUBAI, United Arab Emirates (AP) - Iran has revoked the press accreditation for The New York Times' correspondent based in Tehran without explanation

Donald Trump, Mexico snipe over supposed side deal 2019-06-10 20:36:36An emboldened President Trump said Monday that his tariff threat forced Mexico to strike a border deal, and he vowed that China will be the next targe

Democrats' defense bill challenge Trump on many fronts 2019-06-10 19:42:05The new Democratic majority on the House Armed Services Committee has released its first blueprint for the nation's defense budget, a $733 billion au

Artist pays homage to murdered Colombia rights activists 2019-06-10 19:31:21BOGOTA, Colombia (AP) - The names of the dead are filling Colombia's storied Bolivar Plaza. One by one, renowned artist Doris Salcedo led volunteers

Kim Jong-nam was CIA informant: Report 2019-06-10 18:26:43The murdered half-brother of North Korean dictator Kim Jong-un had been a CIA informant and was killed while on a trip to meet his contact person, the

Simon Groot wins World Food Prize for seed 2019-06-10 17:12:38Dutch seed specialist Simon N. Groot on Monday was named the 2019 World Food Prize laureate for what is being hailed as decades of work creating and p

Vatican rejects transgenderism in 'Male and Female He 2019-06-10 16:43:42VATICAN CITY — The Vatican issued an official document Monday rejecting the idea that people can choose or change their genders and insisting on

Adam Smith, top defense Democrat, fine with new 2019-06-10 14:20:50The top Democrat on the House Armed Services Committee said Monday he backs a permanent U.S. military presence in Poland to restrain Russia — an

Yemeni officials say top diplomat resigned over UN 2019-06-10 14:02:22SANAA, Yemen (AP) - Yemeni officials say the country's foreign minister has submitted his resignation to President Abed Rabbo Mansour Hadi due to dif

CBC | World News

At least 25 dead as Russian jets bomb 2019-06-10 18:17:48Aerial strikes on Monday killed at least 25 people, mostly civilians, in northwestern Syria in the sixth week of a Russian-led military offensive that

Woodstock 50 festival back in limbo as site 2019-06-10 17:56:52The owners of the site that was to host the Woodstock 50 anniversary concert in August have pulled out of the event, leaving its future in question on

'Break the silence': Human rights group urges Ottawa 2019-06-10 17:43:57Ottawa should do more to help political prisoners in Russia as President Vladimir Putin’s regime accelerates a crackdown on dissent, says an int

Conspiracy website Infowars agrees to pay copyright infringement 2019-06-10 17:41:21Conspiracy-promoting website Infowars will pay $15,000 US to resolve a copyright infringement lawsuit over its sales of a poster featuring an image of

Iran has increased production of enriched uranium, UN 2019-06-10 16:44:49Iran has followed through on a threat to accelerate its production of enriched uranium, the head of the UN atomic watchdog said on Monday, depart

Trudeau and Pelosi place bet on NBA championship 2019-06-10 15:34:50Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi ​​​​​​​have placed a friendly wager with o

Pilot dead after helicopter crashes onto roof of 2019-06-10 14:26:39One person is dead after a helicopter crashed onto the roof of a skyscraper in midtown Manhattan around 2 p.m. ET, according to the New York 

Rohingya blame game: efforts to help refugees return 2019-06-10 14:26:10A closer look at the day's most notable stories with The National's Jonathon Gatehouse: Bangladesh prime minister accuses aid groups, Myanmar author

Vatican's official document on gender denounced by LGBT 2019-06-10 11:59:50The Vatican issued an official document Monday rejecting the idea that people can choose or change their genders, which was immediately denounced by L

At least 95 killed in latest attack on 2019-06-10 10:29:06Unknown assailants killed at least 95 people in a central Mali village overnight, government officials say, the latest massacre in a growing ethn

Prince Philip celebrates 98th birthday 2019-06-10 08:04:12Prince Philip is celebrating his 98th birthday today in private as royal members of the family congratulate Queen Elizabeth's husband on social media

Kazakhstan election tarnished by violations of fundamental freedoms, 2019-06-10 06:43:20Kazakhstan's interim president Kassym-Jomart Tokayev, chosen successor of veteran ruler Nursultan Nazarbayev who retains sweeping powers, won a snap

NYT > International Home

Raptors Fever Takes Toronto, as a Diverse City 2019-06-10 20:12:25It’s not just about the basketball. The ethnically diverse Raptors reflect Canada’s largest city in the 21st century.

David Ortiz Is Flown to Boston After Shooting 2019-06-10 20:00:16Ortiz was stable enough to be transported, but the attack on the former Red Sox star left many in baseball shaken and searching for a motive.

Justice Dept. Agrees to Turn Over Key Mueller 2019-06-10 19:58:53The scope of the material wasn’t immediately clear, but the House Judiciary Committee chairman said it would include “interview notes, fir

N.Y.C. Helicopter Crash Shows Perils of Flying Over 2019-06-10 19:57:48The accident in Midtown Manhattan came less than a month after an aircraft crashed into the Hudson River.

No Secret Immigration Deal Exists With U.S., Mexico’s 2019-06-10 19:48:10The United States and Mexico will review immigration figures in 45 and 90 days, but Marcelo Ebrard directly contradicted the president’s claim o

Helicopter Crash Onto Roof of Manhattan Building Kills 2019-06-10 19:43:52The accident unsettled the city, but Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo said there was no indication that it was linked to terrorism.

Elizabeth Warren Has Lots of Plans. Together, They 2019-06-10 19:43:52Ms. Warren could face a difficult path to winning over moderates, but by pushing out so many proposals so early, she is forcing her Democratic rivals

Inspectors Say Iran Is Increasing Production of Nuclear 2019-06-10 19:42:18The move, which involves low-enriched uranium, comes after President Trump abandoned the 2015 nuclear deal and as tensions between Tehran and Washingt

London Zoo Defends Return of Late-Night Parties Among 2019-06-10 19:42:18Activists say the mix of alcohol and music at the event, which is intended to bring visitors closer to the wildlife and raise conservation funds, is i

The Story Behind the Police Commissioner’s Handwritten Stonewall 2019-06-10 19:40:13The police had long refused to apologize for the violent 1969 raid that galvanized the modern gay rights movement. Commissioner James O’Neill de

Missouri’s Last Abortion Clinic Wins Temporary Reprieve in 2019-06-10 19:33:59A St. Louis judge issued a preliminary injunction that will keep the state’s only abortion clinic open. The state has until June 21 to make a de

Robert Mueller, Mexico, Mindy Kaling: Your Monday Evening 2019-06-10 19:31:41Here’s what you need to know at the end of the day.

Reuters: World News

Italy's coalition to work to avert EU disciplinary 2019-06-11 05:13:50Italy's coalition leaders have agreed to work together to avert European Union disciplinary action over Rome's worsening public finances after a lat

Six die in fire in Ukraine psychiatric clinic 2019-06-11 05:13:16Six people died in a fire in a municipal psychiatric clinic in the Ukrainian southern port of Odessa, Ukraine's emergencies service said on Tuesday.

UK PM candidate Leadsom: Brexit on Oct. 31 2019-06-11 05:08:03Andrea Leadsom, one of the candidates vying to replace British Prime Minister Theresa May, said on Tuesday she would seek a managed Brexit but that le

Indian court orders release of journalist held for 2019-06-11 05:02:47India's top court on Monday ordered the release of a journalist arrested for a social media post about a Hindu nationalist state chief minister, in a

Hong Kong gears up for protests, strikes as 2019-06-11 04:48:32Hong Kong geared for more protests, including strikes, transport go-slows and even picnics, against a proposed extradition law that would allow people

Thousands stranded, five killed, as heavy rain lashes 2019-06-11 04:37:37Thousands of people have been stranded and at least five killed amid torrential rain throughout central and southern China, with authorities bracing t

Three missing after blast on oil tanker in 2019-06-11 04:26:58Three people were missing and two injured on Tuesday after a blast on an oil tanker caused a fire while it was pumping oil in the southern Russian por

Four bodies found as salvage crews lift capsized 2019-06-11 04:25:30Salvage crews recovered four bodies on Tuesday as they slowly lifted the wreck of a boat two weeks after it capsized on the Danube River in Budapest w

Turkey chafes at U.S. pressure over Russian defenses 2019-06-11 04:22:07Turkey said on Tuesday a U.S. House of Representatives' resolution condemning Ankara's purchase of Russian defense systems and urging potential sanc

New Zealand court orders government to reconsider first 2019-06-11 04:14:58New Zealand's Court of Appeal on Tuesday ordered the government to reassess its decision to extradite a man to China to face murder charges due to hu

Putin ally calls drugs case against Russian journalist 2019-06-11 04:07:36Valentina Matviyenko, the speaker of Russia's upper house of parliament, on Tuesday called the case against Ivan Golunov, an investigative journalist

Thai coup leader completes transition to elected PM, 2019-06-11 03:57:03Thailand's king formally endorsed former army chief General Prayuth Chan-ocha as an elected prime minister on Tuesday, five years after he seized pow

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.